What Might G.K. Chesterton say about scrapping the minimum wage?
It is a curious thing, how modern reformers will stride into the marketplace like prophets, waving their arms and declaring that the ancient and ordinary protections of the poor are suddenly the engines of national ruin. One might imagine, listening to such pronouncements, that the minimum wage were not a modest fence around the labourer’s dignity, but a monstrous idol demanding sacrifices of prosperity. Yet the truth is simpler, and far more human. The wage floor is not a chain around the ankle of enterprise; it is a reminder that civilisation begins with the recognition that a man’s labour is not a trinket to be bartered at the lowest possible price, but a participation in the common good.
The notion that abolishing the minimum wage would unleash some golden age of thrift and industry is one of those bright, brittle ideas that shatter the moment they touch the earth. It imagines the economy as a machine, humming along in perfect efficiency, if only we would remove the “obstructions” of fairness. But economies are not machines; they are parades of people, each with a face, a family, and a hope. To argue that wages must fall so that prices may rise more gently is to suggest that the poor should be made poorer so that the rich may be less inconvenienced. It is the sort of logic that would have made Dickens reach for his pen.
And as for the claim that the minimum wage “denies people second jobs”, it is a marvel of modern rhetoric: the idea that the cure for hardship is not a living wage, but the liberty to work oneself into exhaustion. The medieval serf, at least, was spared the indignity of being told that his bondage was a privilege. A society that congratulates itself for offering its citizens the freedom to toil endlessly is not a society that has discovered liberty; it is one that has forgotten leisure, charity, and the Sabbath.
The minimum wage may not be perfect. No human institution is. But to abolish it in the name of economic purity is to mistake the purpose of an economy altogether. The object of production is not profit, but people. And any civilisation that forgets this will soon find that it has produced everything except happiness.
It is a curious thing, how modern reformers will stride into the marketplace like prophets, waving their arms and declaring that the ancient and ordinary protections of the poor are suddenly the engines of national ruin. One might imagine, listening to such pronouncements, that the minimum wage were not a modest fence around the labourer’s dignity, but a monstrous idol demanding sacrifices of prosperity. Yet the truth is simpler, and far more human. The wage floor is not a chain around the ankle of enterprise; it is a reminder that civilisation begins with the recognition that a man’s labour is not a trinket to be bartered at the lowest possible price, but a participation in the common good.
The notion that abolishing the minimum wage would unleash some golden age of thrift and industry is one of those bright, brittle ideas that shatter the moment they touch the earth. It imagines the economy as a machine, humming along in perfect efficiency, if only we would remove the “obstructions” of fairness. But economies are not machines; they are parades of people, each with a face, a family, and a hope. To argue that wages must fall so that prices may rise more gently is to suggest that the poor should be made poorer so that the rich may be less inconvenienced. It is the sort of logic that would have made Dickens reach for his pen.
And as for the claim that the minimum wage “denies people second jobs”, it is a marvel of modern rhetoric: the idea that the cure for hardship is not a living wage, but the liberty to work oneself into exhaustion. The medieval serf, at least, was spared the indignity of being told that his bondage was a privilege. A society that congratulates itself for offering its citizens the freedom to toil endlessly is not a society that has discovered liberty; it is one that has forgotten leisure, charity, and the Sabbath.
The minimum wage may not be perfect. No human institution is. But to abolish it in the name of economic purity is to mistake the purpose of an economy altogether. The object of production is not profit, but people. And any civilisation that forgets this will soon find that it has produced everything except happiness.
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment