Monday, 23 March 2026

A Short Story: Have I to die, innocent as I am?














Here is a short story which is a retelling of a bible story of Daniel 13:43 and is also based on a poem of mine. Like my other story, the theme is justice and false witness. But while that was set in a Victorian metropolis, this is set in ancient Israel.

A Short Story: Have I to die, innocent as I am?

The garden behind Susanna’s house was a place of stillness, a place where the air itself seemed to pause in admiration of her gentleness. She walked there often in the heat of the day, seeking shade beneath the old trees whose branches arched like guardians. Her reputation for goodness was known throughout the community, and her kindness had become a kind of shelter for others. Yet it was in this very place of peace that danger crept close.

Two elders of the people, men who were trusted for their wisdom, had allowed desire to twist their hearts. They watched her secretly, each believing himself alone in his longing, until the day they discovered one another’s hidden intent. Shame might have stopped them, but instead they fed each other’s corruption. They waited for a moment when she would be alone, and when it came, they stepped from the shadows with a terrible certainty.

They told her she must lie with them. If she refused, they would accuse her of meeting a young man in secret. Their voices were calm, as if they offered a simple choice, but Susanna felt the world tilt beneath her. She knew the law. She knew the weight of testimony from men of their standing. She knew that innocence alone could not save her. She knew that the testimony of a woman counted for nothing in their society.

She cried out, not in hope of rescue but because truth demanded a voice. Servants came running, startled by her distress, and the elders immediately began their performance. They declared that they had discovered her in adultery. Their words were smooth, their faces grave. The people believed them, for who would doubt such men.

Susanna was brought before the assembly. Her husband stood helpless among the crowd, unable to shield her from the tide of accusation. The elders repeated their story, shaping each detail with the confidence of those who expect to be obeyed. The judges listened, and the verdict seemed inevitable. Susanna lifted her eyes to heaven and whispered, "Have I to die, innocent as I am?". Her voice trembled, yet it carried a strange calm, as if she had already placed her life in the hands of the One who sees all.

She was being led away when a young voice rose above the murmuring crowd. It was Daniel, not yet known as a prophet, but already filled with the Spirit. He cried out that the people were about to shed innocent blood. His certainty startled them. They halted, uneasy, and agreed to hear him.

Daniel asked that the two elders be separated. He questioned each one alone, gently but with piercing clarity. To the first he asked under which tree he had seen the supposed act. The man answered without hesitation. To the second he posed the same question, and the answer was different.

The lie cracked open like a clay pot dropped upon a rock. The crowd gasped. The elders faltered, their confidence dissolving as swiftly as mist in sunlight.

The law they had twisted now turned upon them. Their own false witness condemned them, and they were led away to face the judgment they had intended for Susanna.

Her husband embraced her, trembling with relief, and together they praised the Lord who had heard her cry. Daniel stood nearby, quiet and watchful, as if listening for the next whisper of the Spirit that had spoken through him.

And the garden, once a place of threat, became again a place of peace.

No comments: