Friday, 30 March 2007
Bad (but funny) arguments for God
PARENTAL ARGUMENT
(1) My mommy and daddy told me that God exists.
(2) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM GUITAR MASTERY
(1) Eric Clapton is God.
(2) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM AMERICAN EVANGELISM
(1) Telling people that God exists makes me filthy rich.
(2) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM MANIFESTATIONS
(1) If you turn your head sideways and squint a little, you can see an image of a bearded face in that tortilla.
(2) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM POST-DEATH EXPERIENCE
(1) Person X died an atheist.
(2) He now realizes his mistake.
(3) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM INCOHERENT BABBLE
(1) See that person spazzing on the church floor babbling incoherently?
(2) That's how infinite wisdom reveals itself.
(3) Therefore, God exists.
BENDER'S ARGUMENT(II)
(1) One day, demons were tap-dancing on my roof. I prayed and they went away.
(2) Therefore, demons are really good dancers.
(3) Also, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM IDIOCY
(1) I am an idiot.
(2) Even an idiot can see that God exists.
(3) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM SPAGHETTI
(1) A few people saw something weird in a bowl of spaghetti.
(2) Some Catholics believe that it is the Virgin Mary.
(3) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM STAR TREK
(1) You will be assimilated.
(2) All your salvations belong to us.
(3) Resistance is futile.
(4) Therefore, God exists.
ARGUMENT FROM BEER
(1) "Beer is proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy." - Ben Franklin
(2) Beer exists.
(3) Therefore, God exists
ARGUMENT FROM INTIMIDATION
(1) See this bonfire?
(2) Therefore, God exists.
Thursday, 29 March 2007
Harry Potter and the Advance Publicity Machine
Dawkins Spat
http://books.guardian.co.uk/news/articles/0,,2045102,00.html
The shortlist stage provoked a spat between two eventual winners. They were the atheist scientist Richard Dawkins, Readers Digest author of the year for The God Delusion, and the comedian Peter Kay, whose The Sound of Laughter won Amazon biography of the year. Dawkins was quoted as deriding Kay, whom he thought had written of believing in God because he found the notion comforting. But in a letter to the Guardian, Dawkins said he had been set up by a "hired publicity machine" and apologised.
Above comment in Grauniad on British Book Awards. If Dawkins allowed himself to be set up, knowing his public image (as Mr Pithy Quote Anti-Religious Nutter), and without finding out what Kay had in fact said, what does that say for his judgement of facts elsewhere? In this "sound-bite" age, he should buck the trend and refuse to give out instant quotations until he has examined the evidence. Belief that what people say is true without evidence! Is this what we can expect from the atheists of Oxford? Surely he can do better than that!
Tuesday, 27 March 2007
NT Wright quotes
My proposal is this. When Paul refers to 'the gospel', he is not referring to a system of salvation, though of course the gospel implies and contains this, nor even to the good news that there now is a way of salvation open to all, but rather to the proclamation that the crucified Jesus of Nazareth has been raised from the dead and thereby demonstrated to be both Israel's Messiah and the world's true Lord. 'The gospel' is not 'you can be save, and here's how'; the gospel, for Paul, is 'Jesus Christ is Lord'.
Justification is not 'how someone becomes a Christian'. It is God's declaration about the person who has just become a Christian.
The united multi-ethnic church is a sign of God's healing and remaking of the cosmos and also thereby a sign to Caesar and his followers that his attempted unification of the world is a blasphemous paradoy.
Monday, 26 March 2007
Gilbert Keith Chesterton Answers His Mail
What is the difference between progress and growth?
Signed,
Muddy
Dear Muddy,
The fatal metaphor of progress, which means leaving things behind us, has utterly obscured the real idea of growth, which means leaving things inside us.
Your friend,
G.K. Chesterton
("The Romance of Rhyme," Fancies vs. Fads)
Dear Mr. Chesterton,
What is the difference between happiness and pleasure?
Signed,
Misbehavin'
Dear Misbehavin',
The real difference between the two words is that happiness is an end and pleasure can only be a means.
Your friend,
G.K. Chesterton
(Daily News, April 27, 1912)
What is the difference between an Italian and an Englishman?
Signed,
Mionetto
An Italian will sometimes break things where an Englishman will send for the manager or write to the Times.
Your friend,
G.K. Chesterton
(Illustrated London News, Dec. 2, 1916)
Dear Mr. Chesterton,
What is the difference between individualism and democracy?
Signed,
Mulling
The (Individualists say) that a man must be free as regards his individuality, not merely as regards his citizenship. Democracy declares that a man should have liberty indeed, but should have that liberty which other men have. This (Individualist) school felt that the particular liberty which a man should above all things have, was the liberty which other men did not have. Their individual aimed not merely at being free, but at being unique, indeed, at being solitary. They set the claims of men against the rights of men. Your friend,
G.K. Chesterton
(Daily News, May 26, 1906)
Dear Mr. Chesterton,
What is the difference between religion and superstition?
Signed,
Mystified
Religion is a rare and definite conviction of what this world of ours really is. Superstition is only the commonsense acceptation of what it obviously is. Sane peasants, healthy hunters, are all superstitious; they are superstitious because they are healthy and sane. They have a reasonable fear of the unknown; for superstition is only the creative side of agnosticism. The superstitious man sees quite plainly that the universe is a thing to be feared. The religious man maintains paradoxically that the universe is a thing to be trusted. The awe is certainly the obvious thing; the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdombut not the end.
Your friend,
G.K. Chesterton
(Daily News, June 2, 1906)
Damnation
When people continually and consistently refuse to worship this God, they progressively reflect this image less and less. Instead, they reflect the images of what they are worshipping. Since all else other than the true creator God is heading for death, this means that they buy into a system of death, [which] leads, by one's own choice, to an eventual erasing of that which makes us truly human.
NT Wright, in answer to a request for a definition of what "damnation" means
Monday, 19 March 2007
Gossip
Everest of decency
In an important, little appreciated and utterly tragic principle regulating the structure of nearly all complex systems, building up must be accomplished step by tiny step, whereas destruction need occupy but an instant. In previous essays on the nature of change, I have called this phenomenon the Great Asymmetry (with upper case letters to emphasize the sad generality). Ten thousand acts of kindness done by thousands of people, and slowly building trust and harmony over many years, can be undone by one destructive act of a skilled and committed psychopath. Thus, even if the effects of kindness and evil balance out in the course of history, the Great Asymmetry guarantees that the numbers of kind and evil people could hardly differ more, for thousands of good souls overwhelm each perpetrator of darkness.
I stress this greatly underappreciated point because our error in equating a balance of effects with equality in numbers could lead us to despair about human possibilities, especially at this moment of mourning and questioning; whereas, in reality, the decent multitudes, performing their ten thousand acts of kindness, vastly outnumber the very few depraved people in our midst. Thus, we have every reason to maintain our faith in human kindness, and our hopes for the triumph of human potential, if only we can learn to harness this wellspring of unstinting goodness in nearly all of us.
For this reason, a documentation of the innumerable small acts of kindness, the good deeds that almost always pass beneath our notice for lack of "news value," becomes an imperative duty, a responsibility that might almost be called holy, when we must reaffirm the prevalence of human decency against our preeminent biases for hyping the cataclysmic and ignoring the quotidian. Ordinary kindness trumps paroxysmal evil by at least a million events to one, and we will not grasp this inspiring ratio unless we record the Everest of decency built grain by grain into a mighty fortress taller than any breakable building of mere concrete and steel.
Wednesday, 7 March 2007
The disorders of existence
The Disorder Of Existence
(from Principles of Christian Theology, John Maquarrie, pp 70-73)
A question like this can, of course, be answered only by a broad empirical generalization, and such generalizations can always be challenged. Yet perhaps no one would deny that when we do look at actual human existing, we perceive a massive disorder in existence, a pathology that seems to extend all through existence, whether we consider the community or the individual, and that stultifies it. Because of this prevalent disorder, the potentialities of existence are not actualized as they might be, hut are lost or stunted or distorted. If, as has been claimed above, self-hood is disclosed to us not only as it has actually come about but also in its authentic potentiality, then we cannot fail to be aware of the gulf separating the two, both in ourselves and in the human race generally. This disclosure, as we have seen, belongs peculiarly to conscience as a kind of synoptic self-knowing.
The disorder of human existence can be defined more precisely as imbalance, and in calling it "pathological" I have implicitly compared it to imbalances in the physical organism. But here we are thinking of existential imbalance. The tension between the polar opposites in existence is not maintained, but one overcomes the other and pulls it out of place, so to speak, so that the whole structure is thrown out of joint. The possibilities for such distortion are presumably infinite. In general, however, we can perceive two main directions in which the imbalance takes place, though both may well be present together in a single person or in a single society, in different regards or alternating with each other.
On the one hand are such disorders, individual or social, as pride, tyranny, angelism, utopianism, with all their variations and intermixings. Individualism belongs here too. These disorders arise from reluctance or refusal to give full acceptance and acknowledgment to the facticity, finitude, and, generally, the limitation of human existence, and also from the desire to have a superhuman or godlike existence, free from the restraints that are inseparable from a genuinely human life. Of course, although men may try to get away from the limitations of existence, they cannot escape them, and so their attempted flight results in some such distortion as those that have been mentioned.
On the other hand, there are disorders such as sensual indulgence, insensitivity to others, despair, and the irresponsibility of collectivism. These disorders represent the retreat from possibility, decision-making, responsibility, individual liability and even from rationality. They move in the direction of a subhuman mode of being, that of the animal which is free from care and lives in and for its present. Of course, here again man cannot really relinquish the being that is his own; he cannot attain pure irresponsibility or animality or rid himself of care, but he distorts his being in the attempt.
The two kinds of disorder are found side by side in the same society or even in the same individuals, but by and large the second kind is characteristic of the masses while the first reaches its pitch in the relatively few who become intoxicated and bewitched with the sense of their own power. This first kind of disorder, though no doubt present to some extent among all kinds of people, has shown its most frightening manifestations in the great tyrants of history, and in them perhaps we see existence at its most disordered. Hence it is understandable that interpreters of man from
While perhaps few would deny that there is indeed this massive and manifold disorder of human existence, there would probably be considerable debate as to the extent to which the perversion of existence prevails. Once again, the picture is ambiguous. Calvin, as is well known, taught a doctrine of total depravity, and bluntly characterized "everything proceeding from the corrupt nature of man damnable." This point of view seems to conflict with ordinary experience, for surely anyone who is not a misanthrope will acknowledge that many things proceeding from the "natural man" are not in the slightest degree "damnable": that the view is also unsound theologically will be shown in due course. Yet although Calvin exaggerates the disorder of human existence, such exaggeration may have had some excuse as against tendencies to underestimate the disorder in man's life and to take too facile a view of the matter and too optimistic a prospect of human capacities. Although we must reject as false the idea that human existence is totally disordered, we must acknowledge that the disorder runs pretty deep, and in acknowledging this, we are following not only the belief of the most thoughtful analysts of the human condition but the Christian belief about man from the New Testament on.
Less debatable than the question about the totality of the disorder of existence is that of its universality, understood in the sense of its horizontal spread. Every society acknowledges its injustices and imperfections, and every individual, when pressed, acknowledges his own disorder and his share in the wider disorder. Such an individual is thrown into a situation where disorder is already prevalent, and thus from the beginning he is wrongly oriented, and whatever decisions he makes or policies he adopts are relative to the disordered situation. So we can assert that the disorder is universal in human existence.
Can something be said to define more closely the character of the disorder that afflicts our existence? It has already been described as an "imbalance," in terms of the polarities of existence, and perhaps this model of imbalance is the best available and, as we shall see, one that can be further developed in connection with the idea of selfhood. But other models are useful in lighting up aspects of the disorder. It can be described as "falling," and although this particular term has its origins in religion and myth, it has been brought into secular philosophy by Martin Heidegger and has an obvious usefulness. It suggests failure to attain, falling short of actualization, or falling away from an authentic possibility, without of course implying that one had first arrived there, and then only subsequently fallen away.
Another model is that of "alienation," also used by Heidegger and by many other writers. The description of the various modes of imbalance showed these as a turning away from one or other of the poles of human existence, so that this imbalance becomes an alienation within existence itself. The basic alienation is really from oneself, in the full range of one's possibility and facticity. This in turn leads to alienation from other existents, for, as we have seen, individualism at one extreme and collectivism at the other take the place of authentic community.
Is it not the case, however, that there is still a third level of alienation, a deeper level where one feels alienated from the whole scheme of things? Perhaps this could be called "lostness." It is the sense of being cut off not only from one's own true being or from the being of others, but from all being, so that one has no "place" in the world. This is surely the deepest despair that can arise out of the order of existence.
At this point it is appropriate to introduce the word "sin." It will be remembered that one part of the purpose of this philosophical theology is to describe the situations in which theological or religious words and assertions have their meaning. So far we have been discussing the human condition in secular terms. "Sin" is a religious term, and it has connotations that differentiate it from notions like "guilt" or "wrongdoing," though presumably "sin" includes these notions. What is distinctive in sin, however, is the last point to which we came in our discussion of models of human disorderthe notion of "lostness" of being alienated not only from oneself and from other existents but, at a still deeper level, from all being. The religious man would say that this lostness is separation from God, but until we can study the word "God" more closely, this assertion can be left aside. For the meantime, in accordance with the method of a philosophical theology that proceeds descriptively, we can only ask whether the situation described is one that can be recognized as typical of our human existing in the world. That sin can be understood as "separation" or "missing the mark" or "falling away" in respect of one's relation to oneself or to one's neighbour would perhaps be universally conceded. That it is understood as alienation at a still deeper level is what is asserted in the distinctively religious connotation of the word, and I have tried to show that this religious connotation is firmly grounded in a common and widely recognizable element in man's awareness of his own existence in the world, or, more briefly, in his self-understanding. There is of course much that has still to be unfolded and examined before this as yet vague awareness of being cut off at the deepest level can be properly evaluated. In the meantime, however, it would seem that: our discussion of the disorder in human existence has led us still further in the direction of despairing about man and concluding that his existence cannot make sense.
Already when we had taken note of the polarities and tensions that enter into the constitution of existence, we noted the possibilities for frustration and the frankly despairing views of some philosophers. Now that we have seen how, in actual existing, frustration and distortion do come about and how there is universal disorder, imbalance, falling, alienation, or however it may appear to us, have we not already reached the stage at which we must simply say that it is hopeless to try to make sense of this strange kind of being that we call "existence" and that we know in the phenomenon of man? At least, we have seen enough to show us that Sartre and those who think like him are far nearer to a realistic appraisal of the human condition than those complacent humanists who believe that with more science and education, better social conditions and the like, the ills of humanity can be cured and a fuller existence enjoyed. These men just have not faced the radical character of existential tension and disorder, and this becomes increasingly clear as the problems of the affluent society show themselves to be just as intractable as those of the impoverished society. Our analysis has rather shown that because of the universality and solidarity of human disorder, there is within the human situation no remedy to hand that will be adequate to overcome the problems of that situation.
We can say then that the alternatives confronting us have been sharpened. Either we must go along with Sartre and company, and acknowledge that life is indeed a useless passion, so that the best we can hope for is to reduce its oppressiveness at one point or another, to patch up the situation here and there, without any hope or possibility of really overcoming the absurdity and frustration that belong intrinsically to human existence, as thrown possibility; " or, if we are seeking to make sense of life and to bring order into existence so that its potentialities can come to fulfilment, we have frankly to acknowledge that we must look for support beyond humanity itself, pervaded as this is with disorder. To put the disjunction in another way: either we acknowledge the absurdity of a situation in which we find ourselves responsible for an existence which we lack the capacity to master, and have just to make the best of a bad job; or else we look for a further dimension in the situation, a depth beyond both man and nature that is open to us in such a way that it can make sense of our finite existence by supporting it and bringing order and fulfilment into it. We see then that the quest for meaning and sense in existence, for order and fulfilment, now takes on a more definitely religious character. Whether there is any support from beyond man such as would make sense of his existence and overcome its frustrations, we cannot yet say. But at least we can see that the idea itself is not an empty one. Our descriptive analysis of the human situation has provided a frame of reference within which this idea can be located, that is to say, assigned its meaning. The term in the religious vocabulary which denotes the idea described is "grace," so it is permissible for us now to introduce this word, in addition to "sin" which appeared earlier in the section.
Of course, in the famous words of
Tuesday, 6 March 2007
Discipline and fear
Discipline, certainly, is needed to keep our loving straight, but not fear; for discipline is an expression of deeper love, it is a going-further, but fear is a drawing back ... Just as the enemy of faith," says John Davies, "is not doubt but the repression of doubt, so the enemy of grace is not guilt but the repression of guilt." Forgiveness sets us free from the repression of guilt, free to be guilty if in fact we are guilty, free to be guilty if it is necessary to become guilty.
This can only be true if forgiveness is continuous, not a past transaction but a ceaseless flow of loving acceptance. Breathing that atmosphere, not only can one forgive, but one can also dare to take the blame, just as Jesus did.
John V Taylor "The Go-Between God" p 173
Hidden Millions of Mass Delusion
Wednesday, 28 February 2007
Mote and Beam
Many successful offshore jurisdictions keep on the right side of the law, and many of the world's richest people and its biggest and most reputable companies use them quite legally to minimise their tax liability.
How does the Economist know that? The very essence of secrecy is that this is not known, and secrecy is the essence of tax havens. This claim could never be proven.
Tuesday, 20 February 2007
Cultural Identity Theft
Declaration of War
Against Exploiters of Lakota Spirituality
First of all; We (meaning A.I.C.S.) did not write this declaration.
It was written by Lakota/Dakota/Nakota Spiritual people.
We do however support, and we encourage others to support, each and every word written here.
Elders don't get around the internet like we do, so they are only partly aware of all the exploitation going on. Support those who wrote these words making it known to the exploiters - we know who and what they are, we do not approve, we are watching, and we are notifying others. Above all else, BOYCOTT the fakes and make sure your friends do not fall victim to them!
At the Lakota Summit V, an international gathering of US and Canadian Lakota, Dakota and Nakota Nations, about 500 representatives from 40 different tribes and bands of the Lakota unanimously passed a "Declaration of War Against Exploiters of Lakota Spirituality." The following declaration was unanimously passed on June 10, 1993
Declaration of War
WHEREAS we are the conveners of an ongoing series of comprehensive forums on the abuse and exploitation of Lakota spirituality; and
WHEREAS we represent the recognized traditional spiritual leaders, traditional elders, and grassroots advocates of the Lakota people; and
WHEREAS for too long we have suffered the unspeakable indignity of having our most precious Lakota ceremonies and spiritual practices desecrated, mocked and abused by non-Indian "wannabes," hucksters, cultists, commercial profiteers and self-styled "New Age shamans" and their followers; and
WHEREAS with horror and outrage we see this disgraceful expropriation of our sacred Lakota traditions has reached epidemic proportions in urban areas throughout the country; and
WHEREAS our precious Sacred Pipe is being desecrated through the sale of pipestone pipes at flea markets, powwows, and "New Age" retail stores; and
WHEREAS pseudo-religious corporations have been formed to charge people money for admission into phony "sweatlodges" and "vision quest" programs; and
WHEREAS sacrilegious "sundances" for non-Indians are being conducted by charlatans and cult leaders who promote abominable and obscene imitations of our sacred Lakota sundance rites; and
WHEREAS non-Indians have organized themselves into imitation "tribes," assigning themselves make-believe "Indian names" to facilitate their wholesale expropriation and commercialization of our Lakota traditions; and
WHEREAS academic disciplines have sprung up at colleges and universities institutionalizing the sacrilegious imitation of our spiritual practices by students and instructors under the guise of educational programs in "shaminism;" and
WHEREAS non-Indian charlatans and "wannabes" are selling books that promote the systematic colonization of our Lakota spirituality; and
WHEREAS the television and film industry continues to saturate the entertainment media with vulgar, sensationalist and grossly distorted representations of Lakota spirituality and culture which reinforce the public's negative stereotyping of Indian people and which gravely impair the self-esteem of our children; and
WHEREAS individuals and groups involved in "the New Age Movement," in "the men's movement," in "neo-paganism" cults and in "shamanism" workshops all have exploited the spiritual traditions of our Lakota people by imitating our ceremonial ways and by mixing such imitation rituals with non-Indian occult practices in an offensive and harmful pseudo-religious hodgepodge; and
WHEREAS the absurd public posturing of this scandalous assortment of psuedo-Indian charlatans, "wannabes," commercial profiteers, cultists and "New Age shamans" comprises a momentous obstacle in the struggle of traditional Lakota people for an adequate public appraisal of the legitimate political, legal and spiritual needs of real Lakota people; and
WHEREAS this exponential exploitation of our Lakota spiritual traditions requires that we take immediate action to defend our most precious Lakota spirituality from further contamination, desecration and abuse;
THEREFORE WE RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS:
1. We hereby and henceforth declare war against all persons who persist in exploiting, abusing and misrepresenting the sacred traditions and spiritual practices of our Lakota, Dakota and Nakota people.
2. We call upon all our Lakota, Dakota and Nakota brothers and sisters from reservations, reserves, and traditional communities in the United States and Canada to actively and vocally oppose this alarming take-over and systematic destruction of our sacred traditions.
3. We urge our people to coordinate with their tribal members living in urban areas to identify instances in which our sacred traditions are being abused, and then to resist this abuse, utilizing whatever specific tactics are necessary and sufficient --for example demonstrations, boycotts, press conferences, and acts of direct intervention.
4. We especially urge all our Lakota, Dakota, and Nakota people to take action to prevent our own people from contributing to and enabling the abuse of our sacred ceremonies and spiritual practices by outsiders; for, as we all know, there are certain ones among our own people who are prostituting our spiritual ways for their own selfish gain, with no regard for the spiritual well-being of the people as a whole.
5. We assert a posture of zero-tolerance for any "white man's shaman" who rises from within our own communities to "authorize" the expropriation of our ceremonial ways by non-Indians; all such "plastic medicine men" are enemies of the Lakota, Dakota and Nakota people.
6. We urge traditional people, tribal leaders, and governing councils of all other Indian nations, to join us in calling for an immediate end to this rampant exploitation of our respective American Indian sacred traditions by issuing statements denouncing such abuse; for it is not the Lakota, Dakota and Nakota people alone whose spiritual practices are being systematically violated by non-Indians.
7. We urge all our Indian brothers and sisters to act decisively and boldly in our present campaign to end the destruction of our sacred traditions, keeping in mind our highest duty as Indian people: to preserve the purity of our precious traditions for our future generations, so that our children and our children's children will survive and prosper in the sacred manner intended for each of our respective peoples by our Creator.
Wilmer Stampede Mesteth; (Oglala Lakota); Traditional Spiritual Leader & Lakota Culture Instructor; Oglala Lakota College, Pine Ridge, South Dakota
Darrell Standing Elk; (Sicangu Lakota); President, Center for the SPIRIT, San Fancisco, California, & Pine Ridge, South Dakota
Phyllis Swift Hawk; (Kul Wicasa Lakota); Tiospaye Wounspe Waokiye; Wanblee, South Dakota
Romany Fake
The pervasiveness of this new-age crystals-and-candles image is nowhere more in evidence than on the E-bay Internet auction site, where "sexy gypsy-wicca blouses" and the like account for almost all of the over two thousand "gypsy" offerings posted there daily (several further examples of this mystical image may be found at http://www.cox-internet.com/gypsie.htm). Another site, "The Gypsy" (at http://larp.com/jahavra/gypsy1.html) informs the visitor that "Gypsies are normally dark skinned with bold flashing eyes; however it is not unusual to find golden or crimson haired Gypsies . . most Gypsies live in traveling wagons called vardos . . . the campfire is the center of Gypsy family life; the three distinct nations of the Gypsy are the Lowara, the Ursari and the Kalderasha."
CREATING FAKE ROMANI CULTURE
Ian Hancock
To be fair, not all fake Romani culture has been faked deliberately. More often it is simply the result of misguided or misinformed hypotheses finding their way into the conventional account, and being repeated by subsequent writers unchecked. A prime example of deliberately faked tradition, however, is found in Manfri Fred Woods' much‑publicized In The Life of a Romany Gypsy which appeared in 1973. Here, he summarized on pages 65‑69 what was allegedly remembered of the original Romani religion. He begins "[n]ow, as to Romany religion, there is not much anybody remembers of it today. There was a prophet called Soster, and a lot of the stories had to do with him". Wood then goes on to relate the story of the creation of the universe and the world out of a burst of fire, and of the two gods Moshto and Arivell, and Moshto's three sons, and the ginkgo or maidenhair tree, and of the two clay figures into whose mouths Moshto blew its seeds to give them life.
What is curious is that six years later, Leon Petulengro (Leon Lloyd) repeated the story in his own book Romany Boy, where on pages 136‑137 the same accountof a void within a void, and the explosion of a ball of fire, and of the two gods, Moshto and Arivell, and Moshto's three sons, and the two clay figures, and the ginkgo tree, is told. But this time the story is attributed to his paternal grandmother Anyeta who, he says on page 12, came from Romania. He had already introduced her a decade earlier as "Anyeta, a Romanian Zingari, and a true Romany herbalist" in his The Roots of Health (1968:15), though that book makes no mention of Moshto or the old religion. In Romany Boy (1979:24) her membership in a "tribe" in Romania is referred to, as well as her being the head of her tribe, presumably also in Romania since he states that after coming to England, she "did not live with us but with my father's cousin and his tribe, the Lovells". Oddly, he has her speaking British Romani with native fluency on the same page. In 1936 his father, Gipsy (elsewhere Gypsy) Petulengro, "King of the Romanies" (1968:15) wrote a book of his own entitled A Romany Life, but his mother Anyeta does not appear in it by name even though she is featured throughout quite prominently. He seems to have first introduced the actual name Anyeta in a chain‑letter he circulated in 1940. On pages 2, 25 and 162 of A Romany Life she is referred to as a "Berber", Petulengro Senior's own peculiar notion of Romani origins which he'd already spelt out in The Listener (1935: 649) a year earlier. In an essay there, he wrote that
The Romanies are not Egyptians, nor descendants of Egyptians, as many people seem to think. The Romanies are descendants of the Berbers, who trekked to practically every country in the world.
There is much else to question in A Romany Lifethus the spurious jargon presented as Romani (pages 33, 49 and passim), and the use of uniquely British forms presented as Romanian Vlax (boro‑roy, tarno, rokkered), contrasting with Continental Romani pronunciations presented as the dialect spoken in England (e.g. yag-kash for yog-koshter, 'firewood') in his Listener essays on British Romani life. In The Roots of Health the slogan kooshti sante! appears more than once as Romani for "good health", though sante (santé) is a French word.
The question arises: who was the original owner of the Moshto story? Evidently Wood, since his version predates Petulengro's by six years. He linked it to general but fading community memory, while Petulengro on the other hand attributed it specifically to his grandmother from Romania, though in an account so similar to Woods' as scarcely to be coincidence.
The most detailed study of Romani spiritual belief among Romanian (Vlax) Romanies is Chatard & Bernard (1959). Here (pages 22‑26) some of this story appears, although there is no reference to Moshto or Arivell by name. Instead, there are O Pouro Del and O Bheng, which is to say "the old god" and "the devil" in Vlax Romani. The two clay figures are mentioned, and called Damo and Yehwah, clearly Adam and Eve. They are brought to life not by the seeds of the maidenhair tree, but by O Pouro Del's touching each of them with his wand. Wlislocki (1890) doesn't include the story, nor is it found in the imaginative works of Jean‑Claude Frère (1973) or Françoise Cozannet (1973). The equally suspect Clébert (1961) relies on Chatard & Bernard, but does refer to a similarity with Zoroastrianism and Manichæanism, while Elysseeff (1890:169), summarizing Kounavine's concocted work, wrote that
The essence of the primitive beliefs of the Gypsies [is] borrowed from the different religions encountered by the Gypsies on their journey, and particularly those borrowed from the religion of Zoroaster.
Kounavine was one of the boldest concocters of fake Romani culture, claiming that he found Brahma, Indra, Lakshmi, Ahriman and other deities being worshipped by name among Romanies in Russia, who (he said) had also retained a number of elaborate Hindu prayers. But we learn about his "immense store of [Romani] materials" only at second hand in the same article by Elysseeff, none of which can be examined at first hand since Kounavine says he lost it all in the snows of Siberia. Sampson has already commented on Kounavine as "not to be taken too seriously" (1907:7), pointing out that one of the alternative names he gives for Brahma is Khakhava (XAXABA in the original, i.e. xoxavav) which in Romani means "I deceive"the word itself has passed into Russian slang with a similar meaning. Was this given him by a Romani interviewee who was having fun with the inquisitive gadjo, or was Kounavine himself having a private joke at the expense of his readers?
Correspondence within its inner circle during the early years of the Gypsy Lore Society contained a number of risqué exchanges, with "Romani words providing a coded language" (Sampson, 1997:111, where John Sampson's verses composed for Dora Yates provide just one example). These were not usually meant for its general membership but rather as in-group humour to be understood and appreciated only by the initiates. Did this sometimes deliberately find its way into material for a wider, though unsuspecting, audience, perhaps like Kounavine's Khakhava or Frank Elmény's heroine Gali Minsh (i.e. kali mind) in his novel Poor Janos, thereby compounding the fun?
Some wordlists reflect legitimate misunderstandings recorded in earnest, such as Sinclair's (1915) brokla for "cabbage" (actually the English word "broccoli") or karri, korri listed to mean "cock, domestic fowl" (the actual meaning is "penis"); Prince (1907), probably lifting from Smart (1863:7) where the same mistake occurs, has kovaskaruk "willow, laurel" when this is simply kova's a ruk, i.e. "that's a tree". Even Manfri Fred Wood, in the wordlist at the end of his book (op. cit., 122), lists becker as "fruit", evidently a misreading of the entry in a lexicon he had of English Romani collected by a site worker called Alice Bartlett, where she had it correctly glossed, though poorly handwritten, as "frog". Wood's mistake is now listed in Hayward's Romany Dictionary (2003:38,108). One may imagine Vasily Zuev pointing to a window in an attempt to collect the Romani word for 'glass,' for which word he entered xiv, 'hole' instead in his word-list (1789:124). This latter is also used for 'window' (cf. Angloromani dikin-hev). Bryant (1785) lists bauro beval acochenos for "storm" ("big wind a-catchin' us") and porcherie for "brass" (actually posh hori, "halfpenny"); Harriot (1830) has charicklo "cage" when the word means "bird," and vailgoro "fair (skinned)" when it means "fair, carnival." Roberts (1836) has chivya "tongs" when it means "tongues;" Smart (1863) has sorto-poov for "garden" when what he heard was "sort o' phuv," i.e. "sort of ground." Leland (1882) has gogemars for "swamps" (he heard the English word "quagmires") and kris for "mustard" (deduced from "mustard and creese," i.e. "cress" in the London dialect).
But sometimes these collectors were the innocent dupes of their informants and such errors were deliberately provided; Otto Duhmberg's 1870 wordlist of Siberian Romani for example has the entry kari glossed as "grandson", chamrimintsch (i.e. xa miri mind) as "granddaughter" and bremintsch (i.e. bari mind) for "donkey". Bryant (op. cit., 390) records ming for "father;" Sampson (1891: 59) has written about the frequent offering of this particular word to lexicographers.
But to return to Moshto. Given that Clébert's very popular book became widely available in English in a Penguin paperback edition in 1967, the possibility must be considered that Manfri Wood, or else his ghost‑writer John Brune used this as a general source and subsequently sought out some literature on the Zoroastrian religionand as a result, on the basis of the original Zoroaster, Ahriman and Mazda created the names Soster, Arivell and Moshto (this last perhaps also influenced by the Romani word mishto "well, good"). Six years later, Leon Petulengro (or perhaps his ghost‑writer Betty Messenger) plagiarized it practically word for word.
Leon Petulengro's father was Walter Lloyd, a herbalist from Rochdale, who wrote under the name Gipsy (or Gypsy, and also sometimes Xavier) Petulengro. By his own account (1935:80) his family name "Lloyd" was a re‑spelling of the Welsh word llwyd meaning "grey" but which, he maintained, was in their case really an anglicization of the Romani word for horse, grai.
For a while he also called himself Walter Smith. A smith is a petulengro in Borrovian Romani, more accurately petalengro (from petalo, "horseshoe"his own 'spelling pronunciation' of the word as pet-yew-lengro is evidence enough that he was not familiar with it as actually spoken), and he claimed to be a direct descendant of Borrow's Jasper Petulengro; the information that "Gypsy Petulengro is the grandson of Tinker Petulengro immortalised by George Borrow" appears under his name in the Listener series, and in his book (on the second page) he recounts that
[as a child in Romania] I could not speak English, although my father spoke English and Welsh being the son of Tinker Jasper Petulengro immortalized by George Borrow in his books.
One wonders how he ever communicated with his father if he didn't speak English himself; his father, after all, revealed all of Anyeta's herbal mysteries to him "when [he] was a boy" (1968:15). Yet it could not have been in Angloromani, itself a register of English, and spoken very far away indeed from Romania. Furthermore, since Jasper Petulengro (George Smith in real life) was in fact from East Anglia, why would his son, Leon's father, necessarily have spoken Welsh?
Fred Wood's story has been picked up and woven into at least one published work of fiction, Charles De Lint's Mulengro: A Romany Tale (1985), where Moshto is mentioned on pages 87 and 277, as well as into several websites (Gypsy Phoenix Rising's "Gypsy" site at http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Sparta/ 7313/gyps.html and another at http:// riverendell. fortunecity.com/ legions/379/fullstory4.html are just two examples); it has also found its way into academic treatises and been retold as though it were fact. Thus W.R. Rishi, in his book Roma writes (1976:79), with his own additions, that
the supreme god is Moshto (from the Romani word mishto meaning good) symbol of goodness, and Arivell (from Sanskrit ari 'enemy'), the symbol of evil. Moshto's three sons are the trinity of Hindu gods, Brahma (the creator), Vishnu (the sustainer) and Shiva (the killer of all that is evil).
At the same section in his book, Rishi also paraphrases and quotes Kounavine extensively as fact. Dennis Liggio dealt with it as real in an unpublished essay entitled The Influences of Zoroastrianism and Manichæanism on the Romani Creation Myth (1996), while John McLaughlin, a professor at The University of Illinois, recounts it in detail in his book Gypsy Lifestyles (1980:4‑7). Taking his cue, though maybe unwittingly, from Leon Petulengro, McLaughlin elaborated the story with embellishments of his own, stating (on pages 6-7) that
Moshto laid down strict rules of cleanliness to ward off disease, and many of these practices are still followed today by the gypsies . . . As will become clear later, the gypsies believe these stories, and they have a serious impact on gypsy life.
At any rate Professor McLaughlin evidently believes that Romanies believe them, and his widely‑consulted book has certainly helped to entrench this concocted folklore yet more firmly in the ubiquitous and alternative Romani historical identity that continues to misdirect and misinform the interested scholar. I personally have not met nor heard of anyone, whether Romanichal or Vlax, who was acquainted with the Moshto story, and there is every indication that it originated with Wood, though likelier with John Brune.
This is not the only spurious account of the original Romani religion. More recently, Patrick Jasper Lee has begun offering courses on "Romany Gypsy Jal" through his Romani Life Foundation website (http://www. romanilife.com), though curiously there is no mention of it in his earlier book (Lee, 2000). This is a philosophy which, he says "originated in India and was carried into Europe by the Romany Gypsies 500 years ago," and which he describes as "the religion that became lost . . the indigenous culture" of the Romani people. Jal is said to be cognate with the English word "year" and the German "Jahr," and to mean "to journey" or "to go;" one meditational practice intended for self-empowerment is the Nogo Jal Drom or "personal Jal road." Jal, however, is a word specific to the Romanichal dialect, and while it does mean "go," it originates in the Common Romani inflected form that means "he goes"Romani doesn't have infinitive verbsand so this can hardly be an ancient term in the language. Still more specifically English Romani is the word nogo; it means "own" in that dialect, but it isn't originally Romani at all, instead being a word adopted from German "(mei)n eige(n)" during the migration through northern Europe into the British Isles; several other German words have found their way into the Romanichal dialect as well, such as waffodi ("bad"), foshena ("fake") and swegla ("tobacco pipe"). The late Henry Sherriff claimed to "still speak the inflected puri chib, and thereby to be the last speaker in the country" and wrote extensive letters from prison in it to his lawyer friend Richard Wade, but upon investigation "it quickly became apparent that huge chunks of [his] puri chib Anglo Romani were actually lifted, often verbatim, from other books, especially Smart and Crofton" (Dawson, 1988:ix-x).
The fact that some of these invented "facts" originate with Romanies themselvesand we may add Ray Buckland, Lee Fuhler and Patronella Cooper to the list (see bibliography) is distressing, since it gives the stamp of legitimacy to such misinformation and, when exposed, only reinforces the image of untrustworthiness we must live with. It also suggests that while these authors may indeed have one or more Romani forebears, that fact is only incidental to their real life, which clearly lacks any first-hand involvement with the day-to-day Romani world; they have accepted instead the 'magical' pop-culture stereotype created by non-Romanies. If they are fully aware of what they are doing and are exploiting such misinformation solely for profit, then they do no credit to the people they claim to represent, and seriously hold back the Romani human rights effort.
The pervasiveness of this new-age crystals-and-candles image is nowhere more in evidence than on the E-bay Internet auction site, where "sexy gypsy-wicca blouses" and the like account for almost all of the over two thousand "gypsy" offerings posted there daily (several further examples of this mystical image may be found at http://www.cox-internet.com/gypsie.htm). Another site, "The Gypsy" (at http://larp.com/jahavra/gypsy1.html) informs the visitor that "Gypsies are normally dark skinned with bold flashing eyes; however it is not unusual to find golden or crimson haired Gypsies . . most Gypsies live in traveling wagons called vardos . . . the campfire is the center of Gypsy family life; the three distinct nations of the Gypsy are the Lowara, the Ursari and the Kalderasha."
Romani Studies has lent itself easily to scholarly fabrication, and the literature is replete with it; Decourdemanche's "Romani script" reproduced uncritically by Clébert is one well‑known example, as are the off-colour sentences that appear inserted into one version of Andrew Boorde's 1542 text of early British Romani ("Mayde shew us yr tyttes" Achae te sycke vesse meng itirrae berkes, "Mayde prythee doff thyn knyckeres" Achae te lelle patouty tirrae drawers, "Allo darling give us one off ye wrysste then" A pirani te des mai cabbe rancke), as sexist as they are mocking of Romani historiography.
Other Romani "facts" which, once claimed, may get repeated ad infinitum have to do with the vocabulary of the language. These have without exception been made by people who don't speak Romani, but whose authority shows itself in their perceptions of what Romani should or should not be like. Elsewhere I documented the repetition of the idea that Romani lacks words for "possession" and "duty" from ten different sources (Hancock, 1998), each copying from its predecessor over a period of more than a century, and seemingly having originated with statements first found in Grellmann (1807). Eleanor Smith writes that "in the gypsy language the words 'divine' and 'devilish' are the same" (1943:59) a novelist, incidentally, whom Angus Fraser called "desperately fond of inventing fantasies about herself, [and who] liked to claim Gypsy blood" (1994:29). These two words, both native to the language, could not be more different, viz. devlikano and bengesko. Similar statements from other writers maintain that Romani does not have words for "truth", "beautiful", "read", "write", "time", "danger", "warmth" and "quiet".
An example of the inaccurate, though probably not deliberate, presentation of Romani custom and belief is in Barbara Walker's Women's Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets which appeared in 1983, and which contains many Roma-related references throughout, all written in the past tense and all with a feminist (and often anti-male) bias. One example of this reads "[t]he matriarch was the center of Gypsy tribal life; everything that went on around a tribal mother resembled the old pagan sex rites. Her husband was a drone, whose function was to impregnate her . . . if he failed to beget perfect children, the tribe 'accidentally' killed him" (p. 361). Like other concocters, Walker based her statements not on first-hand acquaintance with Romanies, but on the writings of others, in this case Derlon (1977). An examination of that book reveals that Derlon's already lurid descriptions had been very freely elaborated upon further by Walker who, like Rishi and McLaughlin, could not resist the urge to editorialize, pad and reinterpret.
Elsewhere she states that "together with 'Smith', 'Faa' is the most common gypsy surname', and means 'fay' or 'fairy'" (p. 361). But this is in fact an old lowland Scottish surname and not Romani in origin at all, and was adopted only after Romanies arrived in Scotland in the late 1400s. Again, "the popular gypsy surname Kaldera or Kalderas may have been derived from [the name of the Hindu goddess] Kali‑Devi" (p. 363). The reference given for this is Esty (1969:67) which, on being consulted, actually says that " . . . the Kaldera tribe, that huge group of Gypsies spread halfway around the world . . . governed in patriarchal fashion. There is no king or chief: all the men in the vitsa make all the decisions". No mention of Barbara Walker's Kaldera, or of popularity, or of surnames, although Esty does state incorrectly that Kaldera Romanies have no leaders. The word itself is Romanian for "coppersmith," and cognate with the English word "cauldron."
Another example of what is probably a deliberate concoction is found in John Geipel's book The Europeans (1969). A serious historical and linguistic study it includes Romani, stating in a footnote
A gipsy street seller of lucky charms recently told the author in the Portobello Road, 'Well, if you putches me, baw, cheeros is vassavo just now. We on'y bickins about desh cawlie matchkers in a sawler. Gi's a coupla tringerooshies for a cuppa mooter an' a packet o' tooves, wontcher?' ("Well, if you asks me, mate, times is hard just now. We only sells about ten black cats in a morning. Give us a couple of bob for a cup of tea and some cigarettes, won't you?" a fantastic mixture of English, cant, Sanskrit, Turkish, Slavic and possibly German)! (op. cit., p. 90).
While it's conceivable that this could have happened, it is most unlikely that it in fact did. Why would a Romanichal use his ethnolect with a total stranger, expecting him to understand it? The sentence would appear to be a Borromani concoction, but it misinterprets cheeros as a plural noun, and he has the man asking for a cup of urine. Like Winifred Lehmann, whose Romani sample in his linguistics textbook contains not a word of Romani (1983: 214), academic rigour can get less attention when it comes to Romanies and the Romani language.
In 1973, Dodgson drew attention to what he hoped might have been the very first documented sample of written Romani: a rhyme apparently published in 1517, a full quarter-century earlier than Boorde's sentences referred to above. He had come across the following bawdy incantation while thumbing through a (then) recently-published book on witchcraft by Peter Haining (1972):
Dui rika hin mire mine
Dui yara hin leskro kor
Avnas dui yek jelo
Keren akana yek jeles
As his source for this, Haining listed a work of esoterica entitled the Grimorium Verum, for which he gave a publication date of 1517. Hodgson was unable to locate the Grimorium and so wrote to Peter Haining in care of his publisher. Haining replied that he had also been unable to find the book, but had been given the verses and that reference by an (unidentified) colleague. He also failed to provide a return address. Hodgson then passed the task along to the late Angus Fraser, who ascertained that the book is generally believed by scholars to be an eighteenth, rather than a sixteenth, century work, but who was himself also unable to locate a copy.
The rhyme is in a remarkably standardized spelling for a 16th (or even an 18th) century Romani text, although it contains the misreading mine for minč in its first line. The dialect is a Central one, probably from the Hungarian-Slovak or the Transylvanian lands, and the orthographic conventions are English, not Continental, to judge from the evident values of the 'j' and the 'y'. Given its form, and that it is an incantation to ensure fertility in women, a few readily available sources from which it might have been lifted come at once to mind. The only one aimed at a popular market, however, is Leland (1891), and sure enough, the verse is to be found on page 100 of that book, with the following form:
Dui riká hin mire min
Dui yārá hin leskro kor
Avnás dūi yek jelo
Keren akána yek jeles
Leland made no secret of the fact that many of the rhymes and incantations throughout his book, as well as their orthography, were taken from Wlislocki's various works. Consulting these, the original source for the rhyme in question is revealed in an article by him written in 1887 concerning birth, life and death beliefs among tent-dwelling Romanies in Transylvania.
While Leland is known for his creativity where Romani language and culture are concerned, the culprit this time would appear to be Peter Haining, whose lack of familiarity with Romani orthography, and whose failure to identify his source or to provide his own return address, make him another prime candidate for Concocter of Fake Gypsy History.
Leland himself was probably guiltier of sloppy investigative techniques and an active imagination than of intentionally creating academic hoaxes. He elicited some of his 'Romani' vocabulary from his informants by reading words from a Hindi dictionary to them and asking whether they sounded familiar. Being paid or treated to food and drink for their time, they clearly didn't want to disappoint their interrogator.
His contemporary George Borrow is also responsible for creating non-existent Romani words, which have been picked up from his books and reproduced elsewhere (for example by Pott, 1844, and by Miklosich, 1872) and he may well qualify for the category of deliberate concocter (Hancock, 1997); well over half of the unsubstantiated words in Smart & Crofton's dictionary of English Romani (1875:157-163) originate with Borrow, which they diplomatically say he "procured from various and widespread sources" (op. cit., p. xij). These include words from other Romani dialects which he inserted into English Romani, such as covantza 'anvil' or pishota 'bellows', as well as words with Continental Romani forms distinct from their English Romani equivalents such as pindro 'hoof' and gulo 'sweet' (Angloromani piro, gudlo), and even words from Spanish such as mosco 'a fly' and vol 'to fly'. In addition he created words of his own, such as bolli-mengreskonæs 'after the manner of a Christian' and yeckly 'only' while at the same time calling such fabrications "genuine Gypsy . . . clear-sounding and melodious" (1874:11). An excellent extended discussion of manipulating Romani lexicon is found in Grant (1994).
Borrow's inventiveness is betrayed by his poor knowledge of Romani grammar in his discussion of a verse he calls "the oldest specimen of English Gypsy at present extant, and perhaps the purest . . . at least as old as the time of Elizabeth" (1923:11). The lines in question, with his own translation, are
Coin si deya, coin si dado? ("who's your mother, who's your father")
Pukker mande drey Romanes, ("do thou answer me in Romany")
Ta mande pukkeravava tute ("and I will answer thee.")
Coin is the form of Common Romani kon ("who") which he imported into the Romanichal dialect from his vocabulary of Spanish Romani, though it is not attested in any other dialect; deya and dado are both vocatives and cannot follow the verb si, the former taken from his Lovari wordlist, and not found in Britain (though he does have the British form daiya elsewhere in his book). In the second line, Romanes is an adverb, though he doesn't seem to have realized this; he has it glossed as a noun in his dictionary, and believing it to be a noun has it following the preposition drey. In the form Rumnis it is a noun today, but it would not have been in the sixteenth century. In the third line, he has the inflected locative forms mande and tute ("at me", "at you") functioning as personal pronouns as they do only in Angloromani, while pukkeravava is a causative verb form, meaning "I'm being made to tell". The verses, in British Romani, ought to have read kon si tiri daj, kon si tiro dad, phuker mange romanes tha (me) phukerava tuke.
An amusing though unintentional reinterpretation of a word is found in Sutton's 1982 reprint of Borrow's Lavo-Lil, where the original hin "to void ordure" is glossed as "to avoid ordure". This is modern Angloromani hingger or hinder "defecate".
Two writers who have shamelessly appropriated from each other's work, even to the extent of copying each other's mistakes, are represented in Romani lexicography; we find for example the English Romani word for "hedgehog," hochiwichi, turning up in Romanian Romani wordlists such as that by Kogalnitchan who lists hotschauitscha (1837:60), or Vaillant, who has hoc'awiça (1861:108)though the source of the word is in the regional English dialect urchin (cf. the prickly "sea urchin"), and it exists only in Britain, having first been recorded by Roberts in 1836, Vaillant's and Kogalnicean's unacknowledged source. There is likewise scarcely a dictionary of Caló (Spanish Romani) that is original, each one copying freely from the one preceding it, mistakes and all, usually without a word of acknowledgment.
Roger Moreau has built an entire thesis around a misinterpretation. On the basis of the word "Nawar", the place-name Dasht i Nawar is believed by him to mean "Desert of the Nawar". According to the standard Nelles 1:1,500,000 map of Afghanistan there is a Lake Navar about 90 miles west of Ghazni, and Moreau places his desert next to this. It is posited by him in his book to be the location to which three Indian peoples were taken from India as captives by Mohammed of Ghazni, three distinct ethnic groups who grew together over time to become the ancestors of the Romanies. "Nawar" is an Arabic name for the Domari-speaking Gypsies in the Middle East. Their eventual date of departure for the West, he maintains, was at the end of the 12th century:
"When do you think they left that terrible place on their journey West, Uncle?"
"The year following the Battle of Taraintwenty-five miles north of DelhiAD 1193 would be my guess. In fact I'd put Patsi's shirt on it" (p. 111).
He continues (p. 116) "[t]hey had entered Dasht i Nawar as three separate peoples. Three and a half centuries later they were leaving as a race, the appellations Lohar, Banjara and Kanjar forgotten. Their 'Romany roots' had taken hold". But that would have been in AD 843, over a century before Mohammed of Ghazni was born.
Nawar is the plural of Nuri, elsewhere known as Luri and Luli, and probably adopted by Arabic from the Indian luth, meaning "plunderer" (cf. lur "robber" in Romani). One would assume, then, that the entire toponym were Arabic. However, "Desert of the Nawar" would be sahra' i nawar in that language. The word dat means "rubbish" in Arabic. In Persian, long the lingua franca of Afghanistan, the word for "desert" is either the adopted Arabic sāhra or the native biaban, while Nawar is an Iranian family name entirely unconnected with the Dom. The indigenous language of the area, however, is Pashto, and here, the word for "desert" is dat, and nawār in Pashto means "a cultivated place, a habitation"Dat-i-Nawar, therefore, in the native language of the area, means something like "inhabited desert" rather than "desert of the Nawar". Alternatively, if the lake's name Navar is the source of the toponym, it is hardly likely that a lake in a non-Arabic-speaking country would be named with the Arabic word for "Gypsies". If the area is called dat today (though Dasht i Nawar doesn't appear on the Nelles map) this is surely more recent, and refers to the fact that the lakebed is now dry. The very name Lake Navar indicates that it held water in the past, and it is hard to imagine that 1200 years ago the area adjacent to it would have been a desert and named as such for the Lohar, Banjara and Kanjar that Moreau believes to have occupied it.
Like the Moshto story which has been picked up and repeated as fact in works published subsequently, Moreau's account of Romani origins is likewise already finding adherents. Patrick Lee (op. cit.: 27) says it provides
. . . a more feasible solution to the puzzle of the Gypsies' early days. Roger Moreau . . . suggests that the Gypsies were taken from their homeland in vast numbers as slaves in the ninth century AD by the Afghan-Turks who used them to ferry booty out of India into Afghanistan. Three tribes, the Lohar, the Banjara and the Kanjar, who bore a great resemblance to the Gypsies in Europe and who were also at the lower end of the caste system in India, provided easy pickings for these ruthless marauders in their greed for India's vast wealth.
Besides questioning the actual meaning of Dat-i-Nawar, and therefore the entire hypothesis that rests upon it, the date of the exodus proposed by Moreau (the ninth century) and the identity of the ancestors of the Romanies (from "the lower end of the caste system in India") also bear scrutiny.
Regarding the date, the relocation of the Lohar, Banjara and the Kanjar into non-Indian-speaking territory in the first half of the 9th century does not coincide with the fact that the language or languages which subsequently developed into Romani were still a part of Middle Indo-Aryan at the time of its development into New Indo-Aryan at the beginning of the eleventh century. We know this because of the redistribution of the original Middle Indo-Aryan neuter gender, which became reassigned to either masculine or feminine when it began to be lost. The redistribution of the nouns in Romani which derive from original Middle Indo-Aryan neuters match those in e.g. Hindi and Panjabi at a rate approaching 100%; if pre-Romani had left India in the 800s it would have done so with three grammatical genders, and the subsequent loss of the neuter would have occurred randomly, outside of India. Furthermore, every one of the Persian words in the language is traceable to New Persian only.
Regarding the caste identity of the pre-Roma, Bhalla (1992:331-332), on the basis of bio-anthropological data comparing Romani and Indian blood groups, concludes that
the results of the distance analysis clearly refute the Dom theory. The gene pool of East European Gypsies is more in line with the stock of Indian people represented by Jat Sikhs, Panjabi Hindus and Rajputs, who share a common ethnic substratum. The dominant ethnic element in the Doms and Kolis, the two representatives of the low caste population, is Proto-Australoid, which is not reflected in any sizeable proportion in the genetic makeup of East European Gypsies.
This "common ethnic substratum" is supported by recent and more rigorous serological investigation. A team of researchers at Cowan University's Centre for Human Genetics in Perth, after exhaustive blood samplings from 14 Romani communities throughout Europe, concluded in a report dated June, 2001, that
Analysis of slow-evolving polymorphisms has identified a single paternal and a single maternal lineage of Indian shared by all [Romani] groups . . . these lineages belong to a small subset of the known genetic diversity of the Indian subcontinent. Thus, Roma descend from a small ancestral ethnic minority in the Indian subcontinent that has subsequently fractured into multiple population isolates within Europe.
Elsewhere (Hancock, 2002), I discuss the need for higher academic standards in treatments of Romanies. The very latest authoritative volume, part of Gale Research's Indigenous Peoples of the World Series (Sharp, 2003) still begins "The Gypsies are a nomadic people . . . living and traveling in caravans of colorfully painted wagons," and has all groups belonging to vitsas, a category and a word exclusive to the Vlax Romanies alone. The author also maintains that Romani is not a written language (p. 49), despite abundant evidence to the contrary on the many websites she consulted in preparing the book. That certain authors demonstrate less attention to accuracy may well be a reflection, conscious or not, of the low regard in which they hold Romanies as a people. As controversial as such findings as those of Bhalla and others may be, like the contemporary linguistic research being undertaken by Boretzky, Bakker, Matras, Friedman, Halwachs and others, they are the result of scientific investigation and analysis, and contrast as sharply with the non-academic literature as the image of "gypsies" cultivated by the latter does with true Romani identity. Indeed, a clear parallel is evident here between the two: those writing about Romanies generally maintain scholarly standards; those writing about "small-g gypsies" see no need to do so. The newcomer to the field has a difficult job discerning the two.
When the Cowan findings were made public (in Gresham, et al., 2001), the immediate response from a subscriber on one Romani/Traveller listserve (posted 12:xij:01) and himself an academic was that they were just a "newly souped-up version of racialist thought . . . crap". Such reaction, and the debate it engenders is necessary; it moves the discipline forward and separates the useful lines of pursuit from those leading nowhere; but the arena is not mostly populated by specialists who are in a position to judge and critique the data. The overwhelming majority of those with even a passing interest in Romanies are the same people that might read Stephen King's Thinner or watch Walt Disney's Hunchback of Notre Dame.
Working with my own students over the years, I hear from them repeatedly that they cannot tell whether the sources they are consulting for their own research papers are reliable or not. Should a project on Romani religious belief rely on Wood? Should a study of gender roles use Walker as a source? Is Moreau a good book for early Romani history? All have been assumed to be trustworthy by my students. If there is to be a sincere concern for Romani Studies there must be a sincere concern for Romanies too, and the same criticism we do not hesitate to level at the work of our academic colleagues must extend to the popular treatments which, after all, reach a far larger audience and which help to shape the misconceptions and attitudes associated with the Romani people.
References in the text
Bhalla, V., 1992. "Ethnicity and Indian origins of Gypsies
of Eastern Europe and the USSR", in Singh, pp.
324-346.
Boorde, Andrew, 1542. A Caveat for Common Cursetors.
London.
Borrow, George, 1874. Romano Lavo-Lil: Word-Book of
the Romany, or English Gypsy Language. London:
Murray.
Bryant, Jacob, 1785. "Collections on the Zingara or
Gypsey language," Archæologia, 7:387-394.
Buckland, Ray, 1988. Secrets of Gypsy Fortune Telling.
St. Paul: Llewellyn Publications.
Buckland, Ray, 1990. Gypsy Dream Reading. St. Paul:
Llewellyn Publications.
Buckland, Ray, 1998. Gypsy Love Magick. St. Paul:
Llewellyn Publications.
Buckland, Ray, 1999. Gypsy Dream Dictionary. St. Paul:
Llewellyn Publications.
Buckland, Ray, 2001. The Buckland Romani Tarot: The
Gypsy Book of Wisdom. St. Paul: Llewellyn
Publications.
Chatard, J., & M. Bernard, 1959. Zanko - Chef Tribal.
Paris: La Colombe.
Clébert, J.-P., 1961. Les Tziganes. Paris: Arthaud.
Cooper, Patrinella, 2002. Gypsy Magic. Boston:
Weiser Books.
Cozannet, Françoise, 1973. Mythes et Coutumes
Religieuses des Tziganes. Paris: Payot.
Dawson, Robert, ed., 1988. Henry Dry-Bread: The
Richard Wade Papers. Alfreton: The Derbyshire
Gypsy Liaison Group.
De Lint, Charles, 1985. Mulengro: A Romany Tale. New
York: Ace Books.
Derlon, Pierre, 1977. Secrets of the Gypsies. New York:
Random House.
Dodgson, R., 1973. "Early Romani", The Journal of the
Gypsy Lore Society, Third series, (52:3/4:87-89).
Duhmberg, Otto, 1870. Zigeunerisches aus Sibirien: W`rter
der Zigeunersprache. Tomsk: Government Printing
Office.
Elémeny Frank, 1886. Poor Janos: A Tale of Hungarian Gipsy
Life. London: Henry Vickers.
Elysseeff, A.V., 1890. "Materials for the study of the
Gypsies, collected by M.J. Kounavine", Journal of
the Gypsy Lore Society, 2:93-106, 161-171,
translated from the following:
Elysseeff, A.V., 1881. "Materialax dlja izučenja Cigan
sobrannix M.I. Kunavinom", Geografičeskije
Investija,17(5).
Esty, Katharine, 1969. The Gypsies: Wanderers in Time.
New York: Hawthorn Books.
Fraser, Angus, 1994. "George Borrow as a character in
fiction", The George Borrow Bulletin, :27-30.
Frère, Jean‑Claude, 1973. L'Egnime des Gitans. Paris:
Maison Mame.
Fuhler, Lee John, 1996. Dogstown. Wellington:
Eaglemont Press.
Geipel, John, 1969. The Europeans: The PeopleToday
and Yesterday; Their Origins and Interrelations.
New York: Pegasus Books.
Grant, Anthony, 1994. "Plagiarism and lexical orphans in
the European Romani lexicon", in Matras (ed.),
1994:53-68.
Grellmann, Heinrich, 1807. Dissertation on the Gipseys.
London: Ballantine.
Gresham, David, et al., 2001. "Origins and divergence of
the Roma". American Journal of Human
Genetics, 96:1314-1331.
Haining, Peter, 1972. The Warlocks' Book. London: Allen
& Co.
Hancock, Ian, 1997. "George Borrow's Romani", in
Matras, Bakker & Kyuchukov, eds., 1997:199-214.
Hancock, Ian, 1998. "Duty and beauty, possession and
truth: the claim of lexical impoverishment as control", in Tong, 1998, pp. 115-126.
Hancock, Ian, 2002. We Are the Romani People. Hatfield:
Hertfordshire University Press.
Harriot, John, 1830. "Observations on the oriental origin of
the Romanichal, or tribe miscalled Gypsey or
Bohemian,"Transactions of the Royal Asiatic
Society, 2:518-588.
Hayward, James, 2003. Gypsy Jib: A Romany Dictionary.
Wenhaston: Holm Oak Publishing.
Kogalnicean, Michel de, 1837. Esquisse sur l'Histoire, les
Murs et la Langue des Cigains. Behr: Berlin.
Lee, Patrick Jasper, 2000. We Borrow the Earth: An
Intimate Portrait of the Gypsy Shamanic
Tradition and Culture. London: Thorsons (Harper
Collins).
Lehmann, Winifred, 1983. Descriptive Linguistics: An
Introduction. New York: Random House.
Leland, Charles G., 1882. The Gypsies. Boston: Houghton
Mifflin Co.
Leland, Charles G., 1891. Gypsy Sorcery and Fortune
Telling. London: Unwin.
Liggio, Dennis, 1996. The Influences of Zoroastrianism
and Manichæanism on the Romani Creation Myth.
Austin: The University of Texas.
McLaughlin, John, 1980. Gypsy Lifestyles. Lexington
Heath.
Matras, Y., ed., 1994. Romani in Contact. Amsterdam &
Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Matras, Y., H. Kyuchukov & P. Bakker, eds., 1997. The
Typology and Dialectology of Romani. Amsterdam
& Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Moreau, Roger, 1995. The Rom: Walking in the Paths of
the Gypsies. Toronto: Key Porter Books.
Petulengro, Gipsy (or Gypsy, or Xavier), 1935a.
"Romany". The Listener, April 17, p. 649
Petulengro, Gipsy (or Gypsy or Xavier), 1935b. "Romany".
The Listener, September 4, p. 80.
Petulengro, Gipsy (or Gypsy or Xavier), 1936. A Romany
Life. New York: Dutton.
Petulengro, Leon (Leon Lloyd), 1968. The Roots of
Health. London: The Souvenir Press.
Petulengro, Leon (Leon Lloyd), 1979). Romany Boy.
London: Hale, London.
Pott, Augustus, 1844. Die Zigeuner in Europa und Asien.
Halle: Heynemann.
Prince, J. Dynley, 1907. "The English-Rommany jargon of
the American roads", Journal of the American
Oriental Society, new series, 2:271-308.
Roberts, Samuel, 1836. The Gypsies. London: Longmans.
Sampson, John, 1891. "Minche." Journal of the Gypsy
Lore Society, 3(1):59.
Sampson, John, 1907. "Gypsy language and origin",
Journal of the Gypsy Lore Society, n.s., 1(1):4-22.
Sampson, Anthony, 1997. The Scholar Gypsy. London:
Murray.
Sharp, Anne W., 2003. The Gypsies. Farmington Hills:
Lucent Books.
Sinclair, A.T., 1915. "An American Romani vocabulary",
Bulletin of the New York Public Library, 9(10):727-
738.
Singh, K.S., ed., 1992. Ethnicity, Caste and People. Delhi
& Moscow: Manohar Publrs.
Smart, Bath C., 1863. "The dialect of the English
Gypsies", Transactions of the Philological Society,
1862-1863, as an appendix.
Smart, Bath C., & H.T. Crofton, 1875. The Dialect of the
English Gypsies. London: Asher & Co.
Smith, Eleanor, 1943. Caravan. Garden City: Doubleday.
Tong, Diane, 1998. Gypsies: An Interdisciplinary Reader.
New York & London: Garland Publishing, Inc.
Vaillant, Jean-Antoine, 1861. Grammaire, Dialogues et
Vocabulaire de la Langue Rommanes des Cigains.
Pilloy: Paris.
Walker, Barbara, 1983. Women's Encyclopedia of Myths
and Secrets. San Francisco: Harper & Row.
Wlislocki, H., 1887. "Gebräuche der transsilvanischen
Zeltzigeuner bei Geburt, Taufe, und Leichen- bestattung" Globus, 51:249-251, 267-70.
Wlislocki, H., 1890. Vom Wandernden Zigeunervolke,
Hamburg: Richet.
Wood, Fred, 1973. In The Life of a Romany Gypsy. London
& Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Vasily Zuev, 1789. Beschreibung seiner Reise von St.
Petersburg nach Cherson in den Jahren 1781 und
1782. Dresden; "Vokabular zu Belgorod in
1783. Russland," pp. 123-134.