Wednesday, 19 March 2008

I'm not sure I like your tone, sir

"I'm not sure I like your tone, sir"  , William Hartnell, The Tenth Planet
 
I've been surveying a few of the other Jersey blogs on the net, and here is a brief review of them. One thing which is common to all of them is a kind of chatty familiarity, which refers to people like Philip Bailhache as "Phil". I think this is a shame, because it sets a tone which detracts from the more serious content. They could give the Baillif his full title, or they could adopt academic policy - scholars normally refer to individuals solely by their full or their last names, omitting courtesy titles. But I think the kind of "matey" polemic which comes out is - if not abusive - certainly rude and discourteous, and comes close to the ad hominem argument, where people are attacked because of who they are, by name calling, and not for their policies and beliefs.
 
This has some very decent arguments, and some good facts. Stuart Syvret is good at opposing the factual inaccuracies of his opponents. For example, on subjects like the Sharp report, when the JEP claimed recently to have published everything there was on record, he noted the singular omission of Francis Hamon who gave Jack Hydes "informal advice" to take no action against complaints by the boys who were abused, or John Le Breton, who is also mentioned in the report and who resigned shortly afterwards.
 
Against this, the reader has to wade through polemic, such as "The community's destiny is in the hands of this collection ignoramuses, deluded egotists and clowns." - as a description of the States of Jersey, or Syvret's repeated calling of the Bailiff as "Phil" and the Attorney-General as "Bill", which is very close to an ad hominem argument, and gives a distinctly unpleasant and chip-on-the-shoulder tone to his blog. 
 
This blog has some very well argued material, together with some very harshly satirical photographs. Of course, satire is part of the rough and tumble of politics. Again some good arguments and observations, for example:
 
When Ministerial government first came into play three years ago, a worrying trait emerged. Little comments began to appear from senior Ministers about Jersey needing to be "a player on the world stage". As those Ministers got used to having their feet under the table they began to commission various architectural projects. The term "world class" has become commonplace when promoting these projects, and there is a definite intent that the designs should compete with the metropolis-sized standards to be found in locations such as Hong Kong, Los Angeles and Sydney. Even a Jersey national anthem has been thrown into the pot.
Alongside that is a kind of polemic that again tends to ruin the serious debate, with the odd sentence like this:
 
Still, I suppose as long as the island's bloated swine get to keep their snouts buried firmly in the swill, there's no need to ask questions or look for a superior or more democratic alternative, is there?
 
There is less of the purple prose than Stuart Syvret's blog, and more decent arguments, but could still be improved. Sentences like that above show opinions with a high degree of resentment, and I'm not sure that kind of tone is helpful in getting the points - which are pretty well argued - over to the general public.
 
 
This is not a blog, but a forum, and the material varies widely from "The Three Stooges - Frank, Phil & Bob", which again has a tone that betrays the serious arguments made. If one is not put off with that kind of polemic, then there is again a decent argument against the Bailiff's saying that Islanders have nothing to feel shameful about:
 
"Whilst it is not immediately comparable, the West has had to apologise for years of slavery. The Australian government has had to apologise for how the aborigines were treated. And Chancellor Merkel herself is now in Israel as I write apologising for the Holocaust. There is nothing wrong with feeling shameful."
 
 
 
 

Tuesday, 18 March 2008

Marshlands and Sea Defences

One effect of global warning, we are warned, is an increase in severe weather systems. When these storms coincide with high spring tides, as they did recently, the result is flooding in low lying areas, and destruction of sea walls.

One of the reason for this, as marine biologist Andrew Syvret pointed out, is the land reclamation. How does this work? I would imagine that by extending St Aubin's bay outward, one result is that the inflow of water is contained, and funnelled. Before reclamation, there might have still been a funnelling effect, but only so far as the shore extended outwards, and the effect of reclaiming land has increased this considerably. We tend to think of the reclaimed land as the new area by the Marina, the Cineworld complex, the Radisson Hotel etc, but there is by far a much larger area of reclaimed land beyond the extent of the harbour, including a complex of industrial buildings (including the bus storage depot), but further out to sea even beyond that. I went out there yesterday to visit a friend who works in that area, and it is a huge area of landfill.

This also explains why Havre des Pas, while buffeted from the sea, did not have quite the same extent of damage. The reclamation site is only on the far side of Havre des Pas, while the rest of the coastline is relatively flat and curving round to Green Island. St Aubin's Bay, on the other hand, has the rocky coast going round to Noirmont on one side, and the reclamation on the other, making a vast pool of water, with nowhere for the water to escape when rushing in with spring tides, and southerly winds, hence the funnel effect.

There are three main troublespots in danger of flooding, and each was flooded.

St Aubin's Harbour, which is low lying, and in fact is in part an earlier experiment in land reclamation saw flooding. Hopefully, this will put paid to foolish notions about land reclamation for car parking, for unless the parking was raised, it would have been the first to be under water, with considerable damage to any cars parked.

Goose Green Marsh is another area (around Beaumont), and here the problem was compounded by the fact that rainwater and sewage systems use the same network, so that groundwater run-off (which was also floodwater run-off) overloads the sewage system, and led to the eruption of sewage into the marsh, when man-hole cover's blew, despite being bolted down. Firmer bolts - contrary to Guy De Faye's alleged ideas - are not the solution; the pressure will either blow them, or the water will back up and come out at the earliest weak points, probably inside people's houses.

St Helier is of course originally a reclaimed marshland, so it is not surprising that areas below sea level, such as Gloucester Street, became flooded, not for the first time. This, of course, is where the sunken road is due to surface as part of the Hopkins Masterplan. That enormously large document devotes just one mention to "risk of flooding" and directs the reader to the appendix, where there is a map of St Helier, the area by Gloucester Street where the road comes up, a grey oval over that site to indicate that is at risk (as if we didn't know), and a marginal note saying that Transport and Technical Services will come up with a solution. As a Masterplan goes, this is a fiasco! Instead of countless pictures of civic squares and the like from around the world - by way of illustration !!! - surely any plan should have had a whole section on the engineering aspects of the tunnel - pump systems, air filtration, running costs of maintenance - and of course prevention of flooding. It is painfully obvious that it has been prepared by architects who have little or know knowledge of civil engineering.

Of course, one option is to increase sea defences, and this is certainly necessary. But it would be foolish to assume that the tide cannot breach these, and the second line of reasoning should consider what defensive measures could be in place to prevent flooding if the tidal defences fail. Worst case scenarios have occurred recently; they may not be so uncommon in the future.

Monday, 17 March 2008

Mr Wordly-Wise

O God, you have searched us out
and known us, and all that we are is
open to you. We confess that we
have sinned: we have used our
power to dominate and our
weakness to manipulate; we have
evaded responsibility and failed to
confront evil; we have denied
dignity to ourselves and to each
other, and fallen into despair.
We turn to you O God; we renounce
evil; we claim your love; we choose
to be made whole.

The Bailiff has weighed into the Jersey situation by saying that "ISLANDERS are not guilty of some unspecified, collective crime of child abuse". But what does he not say? That the Island authorities set up Haut de La Garenne. That by neglect, by ignorance, and by deliberate action the abuse went on concealed for so long and the home was not properly monitored. That is surely enough for a "collective crime" by the States of Jersey, at any rate. And what of those who voted them in, for whom Haut De La Garenne was a bogeyman, something to be scared of as children, and who did not look into the situation when adults?

"We have left undone those things which we ought to have done; And we have done those things which we ought not to have done" says the Book of Common Prayer, echoed in the modern liturgy above - "we have evaded responsibility and failed to confront evil". If the Bailiff can not say these words, if he thinks he has no need to say them, then I hope he does the decent thing and says so, rather than hypocritically attend church services and mouth them. A confession, like a faith, that does not apply to the whole of life, is like a man building his house on sand rather than rock.

If the Bailiff can say "the Island was doing all in its collective power to ensure that the truth came out and that wrongdoers were punished" and speak in this way - collectively - on behalf of the Island, then should it also be noted that "the Island did little all in its collective power to ensure that the truth came out and that wrongdoers were punished", whether by neglect, ignorance, or deliberately?

What are we to make of the fact that the Baillif presents himself as a religious figure on formal occasions, speaking for the Island, but seemingly unable outside of that context to make a confession of sin on behalf of the Island's authorities? Is his religion (and his confession) something tucked away neatly in a box, that never emerges into the light of day?

Soren Kierkegaard wrote "Is this then Christian worship, or is it treating God as a fool, treating Him as a fool by such an official worship, perhaps with the notion that, if only we call this Christianity, we can get away with it, by preacherfying this at Him every Sunday we can make Him believe that this is Christianity?"

Complacency like this taints us all.


http://www.thisisjersey.com/news/shownewsarticle.pl?ArticleID=101416

ISLANDERS are not guilty of some unspecified, collective crime of child abuse and need not hang their heads in shame, the Bailiff has said.

Speaking to the JEP about the police investigation into alleged child abuse at Haut de la Garenne and the way in which the Island has been portrayed by the national media, Sir Philip Bailhache said that the Island was doing all in its collective power to ensure that the truth came out and that wrongdoers were punished.

He described phrases used about Jersey by some of the national media like 'culture of concealment' and 'Island of Secrets' as scurrilous.

'Lines like that taint us all and smear us all with the grime of suspicion,' he said.

Friday, 14 March 2008

It's Pi Day today!

 
It's Pi Day today!



Some interesting stuff on the BBC website. For us mathematical Platonists, pi is as real as a rainbow. I only know Pi approx by heart as 3.1415927, so I'm way below the nerds mentioned below (I do know root 2 and root 3 to the same number of places though!)

Archimedes managed a surprisingly accurate measurement of pi; by a method of differences, he calculated that: "The ratio of the circumference of any circle to its diameter is less than 31/7 but greater than 310/71"

To see how he did it, look here:
http://itech.fgcu.edu/faculty/clindsey/mhf4404/archimedes/archimedes.html

The marvellous Kate Bush, in her album Ariel, has a song called Pi in which she sings her way through over one hundred decimal places of Pi. In fact, she sings 78 decimal places, then loses the next 22 digits before ending with the accurate next 37 digits.

There is some weird and wonderful stuff linking Pi to Stonehenge at:
http://witcombe.sbc.edu/EMIntro.html

I'd be rather suspicious of it; numerologists can do anything; and I've seen links to Stonehenge, Pi and the Great Pyramid (what else!).

Quote:
It's Pi Day, a celebration of the mathematical ratio that man has been trying to unlock for millennia. But why are we driven to find the answers behind it?
As we're all taught at school, pi represents the number you get when you divide the distance around a circle (its circumference) by the distance across (the diameter).

With just a string and a ruler you can quickly measure that pi must be just over three-and-an-eighth (3.125). With more precise measurements, you may be able to narrow it down to 3.14.

SLICE OF PI
3.1415926535 8979323846 2643383279 5028841971


However, if you ask a typical maths nerd, you'll get an earful of pi - 3.14159265 and so on. A surprising number of students have memorised 50 or even 100 digits after the decimal point

The rough ratio of pi 3.14 gives us the date for Pi Day. March 14, or 3/14 in American dating style, makes sense for a celebration of this famous constant.

Coincidentally, Pi Day is also the birthday of Albert Einstein, who no doubt knew more than a little about pi. Pi Day celebrants, usually children with an enthusiastic teacher and a varying degree of personal interest in the subject, learn about pi, circles, and, if they're lucky, eat baked pies of various sorts.

Famous constant

Some classes offer prizes for memorising the most digits of pi, or for creating interesting mnemonic devices. Count the letters in each word of this classic poem:

Sir, I bear a rhyme excelling
In mystic force and magic spelling

And while pi is a number, its importance goes far beyond simple geometry. Pi represents a deep universal mystery - how is it that something this basic, this fundamental to maths and science, could turn out to be so incredibly difficult to pin down?

In fact, it's literally impossible to know what pi is, because its digits rattle off into infinity.

While there are many infinitely long numbers in maths, pi is the only one in which an infinitely simple idea - the circle - unfolds into an infinitely complex value. This paradox drives many people to distraction.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/7296224.stm

Thursday, 13 March 2008

Hard Pressed

Some quotes from Chesterton (in "Heretics") on the press; some seem quite apt with regard to the Jersey Evening Post.
 
On the whole its reporting is fair, but when it comes to political matters, its reporting would certainly not come up to Wikipedia non-POV standards. There is a clear editorial bias.
 
"The only question now is how much longer the fiction will endure that journalists of this order represent public opinion."

"The only inference is that for purposes of real public opinion the press is now a mere plutocratic oligarchy. Doubtless the public buys the wares of these men, for one reason or another. "

"[The press] have no moral courage or immoral courage; their whole method consists in saying, with large and elaborate emphasis, the things which everybody
else says casually, and without remembering what they have said. When they brace themselves up to attack anything, they never reach the point of attacking anything which is large and real, and would resound with the shock."
 
 

Greenfields: Silence is Tarnished Gold

I see that Mr Bellwood has come to an out of court settlement, with non-disclosure as one part of the deal. Evidently the States knew when they were onto a losing streak, but what did emerge suggests a dirty tricks campaign which may have involved post-dated reports, agendas adjusted etc, by some of those above him.
 
Of course, there is no suggestion of a cover-up. Never, fear, there will be an "independent inquiry" into his sacking. Watchers of "Yes Minister" will watch that with interest - think Hutton or Butler report and you may not be far wrong. The terms of the inquiry will undoubtedly be restricted and fixed so as to ensure nothing untoward surfaces.
 
"There were no questions allowed today following the statement."
 
Silence is golden?
 

http://www.communitycare.co.uk/Articles/2008/03/12/107590/jersey-inquiry-promised-as-simon-bellwood-case-settles.html

Jersey: Inquiry promised as Simon Bellwood case settles

Posted: 12 March 2008 | Subscribe Online

writes Maria Ahmed from Jersey


UK social worker Simon Bellwood reached a settlement in his Jersey employment tribunal today, but a full independent inquiry will be launched into his case.
The former manager of a Jersey children's care home has settled his case with the States in the middle of an employment tribunal. Simon Bellwood had claimed unfair dismissal as manager of the Greenfields secure unit. But on Wednesday he and the States issued a statement saying the matter was now resolved with mutual satisfaction.

An independent inquiry is to be launched into his sacking.

Mr Bellwood had told the tribunal he felt undermined by his line manager Joe Kennedy whom he claims did not want him in the post. The former social worker said his superior was territorial and found it hard to pass over the reins when Mr Bellwood took over control of the secure unit from him. The tribunal was adjourned for most of the day while the parties talked.

Later, a joint statement was read on behalf of the States Employment Board and Mr Bellwood.

It said that Mr Bellwood had not been sacked for so-called whistleblowing. He will receive a sum of money in compensation, equal to his statutory and contractural entitlement, but the exact figure has not been disclosed. An independent inquiry will be set up to look into all of the circumstances surrounding the termination of Mr Bellwood's employment. It is unclear at the moment what the scope of this inquiry will be. Both parties are currently refusing to make any further comment.

Mr Bellwood's case is not connected to the ongoing investigation into child abuse allegations at the Haut de la Garenne children's home.


Care manager settles sacking case

Wednesday, 12 March 2008

High Tides and Sunken Roads: The Hopkins Masterplan?

The high winds and high tides saw the crumbling of the sea wall at the end of Victoria Avenue the night before last, and also extensive flooding in Gloucester Street, right up to the Opera House, which was flooded. The area around there was awash with water.

I have a copy of the map which is part of the "Hopkin's Masterplan" in front of me, and the idea is to "join" the waterfront to town by sinking the road, and building an extensive commercial development - as usual beautifully prettyfied - above it. Apparently this can be paid for by the developers, who get the development land, who will meet the entire cost - with a "national art gallery" as a sweetener thrown in for free.

The proposed road sinks down into the underpass just about where it does at present when coming from the tunnel under Fort Regent, and it re-emerges from the depths just around Gloucester Street. That's right, the area that we can expect to be flooded if we get high tides and strong winds. Now wasn't that a bright idea!

I do hope that someone has the sense to bury the plan, rather than the road.

Tuesday, 11 March 2008

Broken Links in the Chains of Command

According to the Citizen's Advice Bureau, the Prison Governor is "Steven Guy-Gibbens who reports to the Minister for Home Affairs"; actually he resigned last year; their site is not up to date. But it suggests he reported directly to the Minister, Wendy Kinnard.

The story from the JEP was that he resigned because of frustration with red tape.

What was clear in an interview he gave was that he had no direct access to the Minister for Home Affairs, Wendy Kinnard, and that his requests for better facilities, more staff and notes of problems with morale and over-crowding - were filtered through the Home Affairs chain of command - and never reached the Minister at all.

Given that this obstruction is very recent, and the resignation only took place last year, it makes one wonder at the way in which Chief Officers "insulate" their Ministers, and - with regard to Haut De La Garenne, and other possible cases of abuse - Blanchepierre, Greenfields.

How likely it was that a Minister - or back then a President of a States Committee - would have been to know what was going on back in the 1960s or 1970s?

I think there are good grounds for supposing that they could have been easily "insulated" from finding out what was happening, and the case of the Prison Governor - in a quite different area - shows how easily this can happen even today!

Note also that he says the bureaucracy was even more strifling than anything in England!!

http://www.thisisjersey.com/news/showarchive.pl?ArticleID=001932&year=

FRUSTRATION over too much bureaucracy in the Island led to La Moye prison governor Steve Guy-Gibbens' surprise resignation this week. In a thinly veiled attack on senior civil service figures, he says he had expected a challenge when he took on the post in 2004, but not such a negative attitude from people outside the prison with whom he was expected to work. Mr
Guy-Gibbens, said that the frustration had proved too much. He said: 'It is the bureaucracy which is so frustrating. Everything takes so long, and in my view that is not a very efficient way of operating. There are so many tiers of administration every step of the way'. Mr Guy-Gibbens worked for the Prison Service of England and Wales for 29 years, the last five at the Prison Service headquarters in Westminster - which he had believed was the height of civil service bureaucracy. 'That was nothing like I have come up against here,' he said. 'I was hoping, in vain, that someone may think we ought to be doing things slightly differently, but that did not happen.'

Published 14/07/2007

Crystals and Strip Mining

New Age shops are full of lovely glittering crystals, but the way in which they are obtained is often very damaging.
 
The site:
http://www.avalonia.co.uk/crystals/tread_gently.htm
has a comment on strip-mining for crystrals:

Open cast or strip mining excavates large chunks of land to extract precious minerals without needing to tunnel below the surface. It can cause short and long term environmental damage through accelerated soil erosion and through acid water damage.

The exposure of exposed fragmented rocks to water can also create acids such as sulphuric acid that degrade the environment. As strip mining eliminates the soil and overlying rock above a mineral deposit, this means that even with replanting after the mining is completed, it will still take many years for vegetation and animals to return to the land

But not all crystals are mined in that way. There are a number of sapphires, for example, that are mined in environmentally friendly ways. For example,

Sapphires are mined today the same as they were thousands of years ago. Most sapphires come from countries that have strict guidelines on how mining may proceed. In Sri Lanka (Ceylon) mining is regulated so that the land is protected from over use. Mining is restricted to small-scale operations where heavy machinery is forbidden.


http://www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com/Sapphires/Education/Mining/

It depends on where they come from, and that is a question that I certainly ask before buying any crystals (and make a nuisance of myself asking and explaining about at New Age fairs, because I think it is important).

Some are helping indiginous, age-old, small scale operations and native communities; others are hacking into the ground, taking what they want in bulk, and leaving the land, and the people who live there, not much the richer because of it; the profits go to the mining companies.

Sapphire producing countries such as Sri Lanka (Ceylon) do not allow environmental or unstable economic mining activities. These responsible fair trade laws are regulated well and have existed for a long time. Some countries such as Burma do not have a very good record for correct environmentally responsible mining. than


So do ask. It is important

Another leak? This isn't a department, it's a colander

Another leak? This isn't a department, it's a colander. - Yes Minister, The Compassionate Society
The ship of state, Bernard, is the only ship that leaks from the top - Yes, Minister, The Bed of Nails

In "Yes Minister", Bernard is worried about leak inquiries. To reassure him, Sir Humphrey Appleby asks Jim Hacker, the Minister, how many leak enquiry reports, in round figures, he had ever seen. The answer, of course, was none - leak enquiries are for setting up - not for reporting.


Listening to Senator Shenton on the leaked emails that had been sent to his Council of Minister colleagues, I was reminded of this, mainly because when pressed by the reporter as to whether there would be an inquiry about the leaked email, he suggested it would be unhelpful at the moment, but might be taken up later. He really seemed to think - as did the reporter - that it might be possible to do something about it.

I really think that watching "Yes Minister" and "Yes Prime Minister" should be compulsory for all States Members, as - also with the Frank Walker and microphone debacle - it would educate them into at least the rudiments of political life, and how to deal with the press, the public, and internal matters, like leaks of emails from colleagues or officials, so that they would be more cautious before sounding off, and the way in which they do so.

Now, of course, the States Members can also make fools of themselves within the States Assembly; take for example, this piece of logic by Senator Ozouf on a 4 year term for Constables:

A 4-year term will not work with a 3-year political cycle. It simply will not work. In 2008 we will have an election for Senators, Constables and Deputies. In 2011, it will be Senators and Deputies. Constables waiting until 2012. 2014 we will have Senators and Deputies, 2016 Constables. How is that going to work with the appointment of Ministers and Scrutineers? How is that going to work with Constables taking a full part in a 3-year cycle? It is just simply nonsense.

Remembering that prior to recent debates, there was no cycle of Constables elections which were in any way "in sync" with any other elections whatsoever, and that Senator Ozouf was quite happy to let that go as the status quo - it was the Constables themselves who sought a single day, and it is clear that this kind of comment is nonsense. If Constables could be elected completely out of synchronisation for decades with the rest of States Members, why can't that continue but with a unitary election day for Constables?

Is it any wonder that John Le Fondre, in the same assembly, said "I will say I am probably slowly losing the will to live"?

Monday, 10 March 2008

Healing Wounded History

Reported in the Guardian: at a press conference yesterday Senator Walker rejected the suggestion that the States of Jersey owed an apology to the victims of child abuse on the island.

Compare that with some quotes below. If Jersey is to achieve closure, it must begin with an apology to the victims for the appalling negligence on the part of the Jersey goverment in the past for the fact that these homes could be set up and operated in such a way, without safeguards. How many years will the victims of abuse have to wait before such old wounds are addressed? Part of the process of healing wounded history is for representatives in the present to take responsibility for the past, and that is the step that still needs to be taken towards reconciling peoples and healing places.

"We have waited nine hundred years for this, ten more minutes won't make much difference." These were the words of a rabbi from a synagogue in Bosnia Herzegovina. My friend John Presdee and his wife Yvonne, having been gripped by the power of apology, were leading a walk of reconciliation down the Crusader route on its 900 anniversary. They had been called by the Lord to visit mosques, synagogues and orthodox churches to confess and apologise for the murder and destruction they had received by Western Christians during those times of appalling suffering. Of course they were not apologizing for Jesus, only for what Christians had done in his name. However, when they met the rabbi, John had forgotten to bring his written apology and so he asked the rabbi to excuse him while he went and fetched it from his hotel room. That was when the rabbi reminded John that his community had been waiting for so long for this to happen.

The Australian government has made a formal apology for the past wrongs caused by successive governments on the indigenous Aboriginal population. Prime Minister Kevin Rudd apologised in parliament to all Aborigines for laws and policies that "inflicted profound grief, suffering and loss".

On 9 December 1999 Liverpool City Council passed a formal motion apologising for the City's part in the slave trade. It was unanimously agreed that Liverpool acknowledges its responsibility for its involvement in three centuries of the slave trade. The City Council has made an unreserved apology for Liverpool's involvement and the continual effect of slavery on Liverpool's black communities.

TONY BLAIR has moved to heal one of the greatest wounds in Anglo-Irish history by criticising Britain for allowing a million people to die in the Great Famine. In the strongest statement by any Prime Minister on the disaster, Mr Blair said that the Government of the time "failed their people" while the famine ravaged Ireland between 1845 and 1850. His statement, read out to a weekend concert in Co Cork marking the 150th anniversary of the tragedy, was hailed last night by John Bruton, the Irish Prime Minister.Mr Bruton said: "While the statement confronts the past honestly, it does so in a way that heals for the future. The Prime Minister is to be complimented for the thought and care shown in this statement."

George Carey, the Archbishop of Canterbury, in a service in Limerick Cathedral, apologized for 800 years of English domination in Ireland. His words were received with applause because his congregation recognized that an old wound was being addressed.


Book of the Blog:

Russ Parker - Healing Wounded History

Rallies and Press Statements

I must say that the "exceedingly low turn out" is a remarkable piece of spin. Channel TV had this as well, saying that "only" about 240 people turned up. I'd be interested in knowing how many people would turn out for a "support Frank Walker" rally.

Turn out for events is always difficult. People have other commitments. Which is why petitions always garner more support.

Elections are, however, a good measure of support for the political system, although a low turn out usually is indicative of a population resigned to lack of change. The way in which Deputies can be elected to the States when they have failed on their policy platforms as Senators, and then continue with that policy platform is most notable. This stretches back at least as far as Clarrie Dupre, voted down as Senator for Tourism policies, re-elected as Deputy, and soon comfortably back in position as President of Tourism Committee. One of the latest to benefit from this strategy was Guy De Faye, voted down from becoming Senator because of his transport policies, and now back in as Deputy, and in charge of Transport.

It will be interesting to see what happens if Senator Walker tries to stand again, especially given (a) his statement at the last elections that this would be his last term of office (b) his statement in this press release that "as Chief Minister, I will do everything within my power to ensure that in the years to come our children are the best protected in Great Britain". How can he do this if he is leaving office later this year? Another example, I fear, of political rhetoric overcoming the ability to engage the brain first.





Chief Minister's media response to today's rally

Whilst it is good for those deeply effected by recent events to have an opportunity to express their emotions, it is clear by the exceedingly low turn out in the Royal Square today, that the Jersey public recognised that organisers were attempting to use this tragedy to their own political advantage.

My hope is that the people of Jersey will now come together to fully support the police investigation and the victims. We need to bring the guilty to justice and to care for all those whose lives have been damaged by their treatment in the past. As Chief Minister, I will do everything within my power to ensure that in the years to come our children are the best protected in Great Britain.

Then we can once again look to the future and restore pride to our Island because, as the Dean has said, Jersey is still a beautiful, delightful, low crime, high achieving place. Despite the horrors that we have had to confront over the last two weeks, that has not changed. That is the real Jersey.

Frank Walker



Mathematical Blunders

Some interesting calculations from the headlines of Saturday's Jersey Evening Post. The year is 2008. Take away 38, which gives 1970. For age 6, this gives 1976. This is not, by most stretches of imagination, except perhaps journalistic imagination, the 1960s.
 
I am sure the tragic story is true; it is just a shame that the Jersey Evening Post can't get the date right. Later in the same report, the preliminary report by Alan Williamson says "Jersey's current child protection provision would score a 2 on a scale of 1 to 4", and then later in the report Mr Williamson is quoted as saying the scale is 0 to 4, which would place 2 bang in the middle. Quite a difference.
 
Does anyone review these articles before they are published? Or is the editing done by Microsoft Word alone?
 
 

 
http://www.thisisjersey.com/news/showarchive.pl?ArticleID=101318

"THE foster daughter of the man who ran Haut de la Garenne in the 1960s claims that he raped her when was ten.
Tina Blee, who was in Jersey yesterday, hopes that her visit will give other victims the strength to break decades of silence and speak out. Now aged 38, she was just six when Colin Tillbrook, the former superintendent at Haut de la Garenne, and his wife gave her a home."

Corrupt cops in Jersey

A few quotes from the Times, below, click on link for full article. Try as I might, I can't remember seeing a JEP article about the earlier investigation on police corruption mentioned below. Is this my errant memory?
 
 
 
Before announcing progress in the inquiry yesterday, Deputy Chief Officer Lenny Harper said he had been facing sustained obstruction from retired officers trying to cover up their own failure to investigate complaints of abuse at Haut de la Garenne, the former children's home.
 
Asked whether there had been pressure to limit the scope of his investigation, Harper, who is from Northern Ireland and has served in Jersey for almost six years, said: "There has been stacks of it. Mainly from ex-cops, corrupt cops who have got friends in among senior politicians on the island. I would not insult the island by saying there is a culture of corruption; there is a cache of corrupt ex-coppers.
 

Harper said the campaign against him had intensified since the discovery of part of a child's skull at Haut de la Garenne brought the inquiry to widespread attention last month.

"There were calls made and anonymous e-mails sent to national newspapers in the past week warning them not to trust the chief officer and myself, and that definitely came from the sister of one of the corrupt cops."

He added: "There is no doubt allegations were made by children in the past and they were simply not dealt with the way they should have been – that includes the police, the social services and everyone else. British police have been invited to Jersey to support this work."

Harper, 56, said the attempts to block his investigation arose from an earlier attack he had mounted on police corruption. He was responsible for sacking a "hard core" of officers who had allegedly demanded sexual favours from members of the public and taken holidays paid for by Jersey businessmen.

He said the former officers – including one high-ranking policeman – threatened him when it became clear his child abuse inquiry would expose their failure to investigate. "I received about 140 abusive letters with threats to burn my house and my car," said Harper. "This happened about a year ago."

 

Sunday, 9 March 2008

Jersey and the Culture of Closeness

I've been reviewing various comments made by Frank Walker and Stuart Syvret about Syvret's being voted out of office.

One thing that is clear is that Syvret is right in one point. The Sharp Report makes it plain that collusion in a policy of concealment, for the sake of appearances, took place at Victoria College by all the officials - school and governors - involved (""The handling of the complaint was "more consistent with protecting a member of staff and the college's reputation in the short-term than safeguarding the best interests of the pupil."). To be too close to people, to socialise with them, and then to take on  criticisms of them is extremely difficult for anyone to do. Too much "glad-handing" is a bad thing. That is a clear and valid criticism.
 
On the other hand, being so aloof that you never even visit staff is also problematic. It certainly seems to give the message that you don't care, and I think that in trying to avoid what he had seen so often, Syvret may have fallen into the equal and opposite error of not communicating enough with his team.
 
How does this impasse get resolved? How does one safeguard against too cosy a relationship with high officials, and yet work well with them? I think one of the basic tenets of counselling is certainly a good one: you should not counsel people whom you know personally. That is because it is all too easy to have a conflict of interests, between friendships and the professional relationship, and that will damage both. The "no socialising" rule would also be a good one to adopt between politicians and their chief officers, because it would ensure that the relationship was strictly professional. The problem is really with politicians, who often want to be liked by their officials (much as they also want to be liked by the general public), and want to short-circuit the more difficult task of working with people and knowing them through the workplace by socialising with them instead.
 
The other thing I think Syvret should have done, which would probably not have endeared him to his officials, would have been to have made spot checks to the various children's homes etc, unannounced, preferably with people trained to spot anything untoward. It is all to easy for people to prepare for a check, and present the best possible side of things for an inspection. A random check makes this more difficult, and really, if they are doing a good job, after making allowances for the fact that everyone at any workplace has bad days, there can really be no problems with this practice. After a while, people will become used to it, and it will not be such a shock.
 
Regarding the allegedly bullying content of his emails to his officials, I would offer few excuses except to say that it would be interesting to see if his officials were being deliberately obstructive, to the point that he lost his temper, as he claims; what were their relies? Or what prompted his outburse? Unfortunately, emails are often sent with extremely little thought ( the appalling "lenny henry" one springs to mind), are easily - and selectively - leaked by mischevious people for their own political ends, and the culture in which the quick email is dashed off is antithetical to closely reasoned argument.
 
 
 
 

Senator Syvret's Sacking

I have been taken to task about the UK media's description of Senator Syvret's sacking as being "for whistlebowing" and directed to the Jersey Government's own version of events; it is also been noted that the police investigation was independent of him.
 
On this I would comment as follows:
 
a) I would not regard the States of Jersey as totally disinterested in presenting an obecjtive point of view. It is clear that underlying Senator Syvret's sacking (or vote of no confidence) lay major disagreements over various child care issues, involving Iris Le Feuvre, the Greenfields home, and also a personality conflict between someone who was undoubtably determined to be a free agent, and a States presided over someone who cleary wanted to excercise control; the blustering prevarication of Mr Walker after Newsnight shows someone else - apart from  Syvret - who cannot bear to be thought of as in the wrong. It is all too easy to direct political issues away from core conflicts and force someone out on side-issues, especially regarding how they behave to their chief officers; just watch Yes Prime Minister, Man Overboard! I think the UK media have seen through this to the real matters which Syvret tried to raise when voted out of office, especially as these came home to roost later.
 
b) The police investigation pre-dated Syvret's involvement, but not the release of the Kathy Bull Report (2001), or the matters raised over the Grand Prix regime at Greenfields, or the release of the Sharp Report, all of which demonstrate a clear determination to expose child abuse whether it occurs and not allow cover-ups. Note that the JEP did not say in its reports that the Sharp Report, according to Syvret, mentioned the involvement in initial concealment by John  Le Breton and Francis Hamon, both of whom seem to have known about accusations against Jervis-Dykes long before the matter became public.
 
 
 
 

Friday, 7 March 2008

Excellent Police Strategy at Haut de La Garenne

I see that an internal (and rather informal and jokey) email sent only to the council of ministers by Ben Shenton has been leaked to the press. At least he had the grace to apologise publically - unlike a certain Chief Minister, whose continual refusal to apologise continues to damage Jersey's reputation, and (for those of us of an older generation) is inconcevable. The sooner he goes, the sooner Jersey has a chance to redeem its reputation, but - as readers of C.P. Snow's "The Affair" would note - some people are so thick-skinned and determined to keep the reigns of power that they never do the honourable thing. But enough of that.

It looks as if Shenton's disapproval of the way the Council of Ministers press conference was "unanimous" without telling him has been damaging, and the knives are out. Hence the leaked email.

The problem is that some serious concerns he raised will now be ignored in preference to the more Sun-Readership issues.

Let's look at one of these.

One question was about the initial press reporting was handled. "Remains of a child" was very ambiguous, and for most of us who heard that police report, it suggested far more that "fragment of a child's skull"; the issue over whether than pre-dates the inquiry was also not made clear at the time.

I imagine that the reason for this was twofold:

a) The police don't want, if they can help it, to release all the information at one time. That way, if a suspect does emerge from the woodwork, they know something that only that suspect also knows, and if they can get him or her to admit that, they are well on the way to building a very credible case. That is true of police work in practice, not just for this inquiry. Admission of "hidden details" is a fundamental strategy; the more that is in the public domain, the more it can be excused by a potential suspect.

b) Lenny Harper undoubtably also wanted to grab a lot of media attention in order to get as large a field of publicity as possible, and spread the net widely. This was so that former residents or staff of Haut De La Garenne, who had left Jersey, and might have pertinent information, would be more likely to come forward. Indeed, some people have come forward from as far as Australia. Also by publicising the numbers of people who had come forward, he hoped to have an escalating effect; as more people came forward, those who had been indimidated by the usual silencing blackmail and threats of the abusers would feel safer speaking out as part of a crowd, and this would snowball. I would say that strategy has been a great success.

I would think that the police strategy has been an extemely good one, and gaining reports from victims before opening the cellar has also led to corroborative evidence coming to light, which again supports the picture what took place there. Once the information about the cellar was public, there is always the danger that a clever lawyer could argue that victims modified stories to take account of that; by taking interviews first, Lenny Harper has avoided that possibility, and can produce a very strong case.

So while Shenton was right to raise these concerns, I think that he should have thought a bit more about why the police adopted the strategy that they did, and even to talk to Lenny Harper directly.

Thursday, 6 March 2008

Harold Shipman's Motivation - Trauma or Narcissism?

I was interesting in checking up on Shipman's motivation, after the suggestion at a talk I attended on Tuesday that it may have been simply down to "distress recordings" of his mother's death. One of the facts that I was not aware of was that - unlike other people that have been traumatised by their mother's death in early childhood, this was not in fact the case. His mother, Vera, died in 1963 from lung cancer when he was 17.
But despite the late age at which this took place, Mavis Klein, writing as a psychotherapist in the Independent at the time of Shipman's death commented that: "Largely unconsciously and informed by a complex mixture of innate temperament and circumstantial early experiences, all human beings are motivated by a personal agenda that aims to give their lives overall meaning and significance. Particularly traumatic experiences in childhood are often the key to accessing an individual's central lifelong heroic quest. "

She goes on to add that:  "In the case of Harold Shipman, his witnessing, at the age of 17, his mother's agonising death from cancer almost certainly explains his multiple murders. I suggest that his lifelong motivation was to free himself of the trauma of his mother's death by rewriting his personal history. His gentle, painless killing of his usually elderly female patients were all bids to make his mother die painlessly. This was mad, not bad. (I believe the relatively few male patients he murdered were stand-ins for himself in a subsidiary bid to end his own suffering.) His undisputed kindness and gentleness as a GP were the sane and laudable way in which he sought to cancel his mother's agony."
But why Shipman, and not countless others who have seen their mother die from cancer? Shipman was not unique. And why late in his career, rather than at an early period? I have to say that I find this kind of unitary explanation unsatisfactory, it is rather like tying down motivations to "selfish genes".
 
The philosopher Paul Browsley commented on the weakness of the Klein position, that it produces one motivation, but ignores all the other possible motivations (see below).  The Independent also looked at the wide range of views about his motivation, and concluded that: "Psychiatrists have expressed many opinions about the mental state of Britain's worst serial killer, but on one thing they are agreed: Shipman was a narcissistic control freak who enjoyed the power his profession gave him over life and death. His arrogance was ultimately his downfall when police used a psychological ploy to break his iron-like conceit during one of the taped interviews conducted after his arrest."
 
It is easy to provide motivations after the event by the bucketful; it is much harder to explain why one single motivator should be the cause. But the fact that he was a  "narcissistic control freak" should surely come into some part of the explanation, especially as it is about the only fact for which we have clear evidence from his behaviour.
 
 
 

 

Letter: Forget psychotherapy, Harold Shipman is simply evil

Paul Brownsey

Sir: With what frightening confidence psychotherapist Mavis Klein informs us of Harold Shipman's motivation: he was trying to free himself of the trauma of his mother's painful illness and death by engaging in gentle painless killing of elderly female patients, the murders being "bids to make his mother die painlessly".

The trouble is that it takes very little thought to come up with a host of other stories purporting to explain his murders. Here are some.

He was consumed with rage against the universe for his mother's death and, because he never had an elderly mother to cherish, sought to deny the same to other people.

Humankind's fundamental fear is that of death, and by killing others Shipman was unconsciously trying to keep death occupied and keep it from his own door.

He was abused as a child, though he has repressed the memory, and by killing people older than himself is getting back at the older generation who failed to protect him.

Everyone is basically murderous and he simply had opportunities to give vent to this urge which most of us don't have.

He suffered from lack of self-esteem, which is known to be the cause of all bad behaviour, and sought to boost his self-esteem by arrogating to himself God's prerogative of deciding when a life shall end.

And so on. How could one ever tell whether Mavis Klein's account, rather than one of these many others, is the truth?

PAUL BROWNSEY

Department of Philosophy

Glasgow University

 


Psychological profile of a narcissistic control freak turned serial killer

Shipman: The Murderer

By Steve Connor
Saturday, 6 January 2001

Was he mad or just plain evil? What was going through the mind of Harold Shipman when he so ruthlessly played God with his patients?

Was he mad or just plain evil? What was going through the mind of Harold Shipman when he so ruthlessly played God with his patients?

Psychiatrists have expressed many opinions about the mental state of Britain's worst serial killer, but on one thing they are agreed: Shipman was a narcissistic control freak who enjoyed the power his profession gave him over life and death. His arrogance was ultimately his downfall when police used a psychological ploy to break his iron-like conceit during one of the taped interviews conducted after his arrest.

The senior policeman in charge of the case deliberately handed over the interview to two less experienced officers, one of whom was a young policewoman Shipman evidently held in contempt.

The tactic was meant to puncture his feeling of selfimportance, which he used to defend himself by answering questions in a pedantic manner to control the course of the interrogation. Throughout the interview, Shipman continued to stare at Marie Snitynksi with a condescending countenance. He thought he had an unassailable intellectual superiority over his interrogators until he was suddenly confronted with unequivocal evidence showing that he had forged computer records.

The interview ended abruptly with Shipman's solicitor asking for a private consultation. After the interviewers had left, Shipman broke down, falling to his knees, sobbing. This, though, was not the remorse of a guilty man but the bitter feelings of frustration from a supremely arrogant person who had been accustomed to being treated with unquestioning authority and respect by his patients.

Richard Badcock, the forensic psychiatrist who saw Shipman on behalf of the police, said that being a control freak in itself cannot be the explanation for his murderous nature.

"There are lots of control freaks out there and they don't all go around killing people. But you have to understand what's important to him, in essence, which is not just self-control but his perception of that control," Dr Badcock said.

"He is very controlling when you're in his presence, rather arrogant. There is a sense that he is very driven about this, not casual. He is behaving like this because it's absolutely important to him to do so," he said.

At 17, Shipman witnessed the slow death of his mother from lung cancer, an experience that is thought to have left a lasting impression. On the day she died, he went for a long run, an unusual act of bereavement.

Some psychologists speculated that his mother's death could have been the source of his morbid fascination in older women. Shipman is thought to be a necrophiliac - not necessarily a sexual interest in the dead, but just in death itself.

But Shipman's main motivation seems to have been his unquestioning belief in his own self-esteem. His narcissism eventually led to his downfall - the forged will he wrote said that the dead woman wanted to reward her doctor for doing so much for the local community.

Gerard Bailes, a consultant psychologist at East Anglia Regional Forensic Science Services, said: "Narcissism would probably be an important factor in his motivation. He considers himself important but everyone else is not. They can't see they have done anything wrong and the more you confront them with what they did, the more they blame you."

Shipman has refused to confess to his crimes and is unlikely now to do so. This is not because he is in self-denial but because he may not see any advantage to it, Mr Bailes said.

 

The Secret People

There is a rally planned in the Royal Square, which seems to be part a remembrance and acknowledgement of the victims of child abuse at Haut de La Garenne, and partly a rallying cry against the perceived failings of the establishment. It reminded me of Chesterton, and slightly adapted, here is the first verse of his own rallying cry for the ordinary people, which he wrote as "the secret people"

Smile at us, pay us, pass us; but do not quite forget,

For we are the people of Jersey, that never has spoken yet.

There is many a fat farmer that drinks less cheerfully,

There is many a free French peasant who is richer and sadder than we.

There are no folk in the whole world so helpless or so wise.

There is hunger in our bellies, there is laughter in our eyes;

You laugh at us and love us, both mugs and eyes are wet:

Only you do not know us. For we have not spoken yet.

Another of the verses also I think sums up the general feeling of unhappiness with the approach (in the media) by the government of Jersey, and in particular, the Chief Minister and his entourage of press officers and civil servants.

They have given us into the hands of the new unhappy lords,
Lords without anger and honour, who dare not carry their swords.
They fight by shuffling papers; they have bright dead alien eyes;
They look at our labour and laughter as a tired man looks at flies.
And the load of their loveless pity is worse than the ancient wrongs,
Their doors are shut in the evenings; and they know no songs.


It is not that these people don't care, because they may well care very much. It is rather that they seem unable to show their emotions, they come out with stock phrases, in a bland, and unemotional manner, rather like a 1950s newsreader dispassionately reading the news. One gets the feeling of 9 to 5 politicians, who switch off at the end of the day - "their doors are shut in the evenings" - and are not to be disturbed..

It is also not helped by the fact that the one instance of emotion shown by Senator Walker was one of anger at Stuart Syvret in which he lashed out in anger, patently unaware of the comments being recorded. But it goes deeper than that. When I hear the phrases "there will be no cover-up, no stone unturned" trotted out time and again - while reports remain out of the public domain - Sharp Report, Bull Report etc, - and there is still no Freedom of Information Law - I am reminded of another time, another speaker:

"I condemn any attempts to cover up in this case, no matter who is involved."

Of course, the same speaker said:

There can be no whitewash at the White House


Wednesday, 5 March 2008

Via Media on Jersey

There is an interesting and "middle way" comment on Jersey in the Independent. It is I think a fair and balanced comment, although I notice that Frank Walker comes in for criticism yet again for "a number of rather insensitive comments", the journalist none the less noted that " islanders were unfailingly courteous, helpful and in general as keen to see justice done as anyone else."
 
He is also quite astute in noting the disparity between rich and poor with regard to the housing market, although I'm not sure that what he says is fair to all States Housing. Some of it - especially outside of St Helier - is very clean and pleasant.  Having delivered leaflets to around 4 housing estates in St Helier for the last election, I would say that most of the St Helier ones certainly could do with paint, and some definitely have urine smells in the public access spaces, and broken windows on the odd floor. A few were pretty pleasant. Going around, door to door, at election time is definitely one way to see the poorer sides of St Helier, and one wishes a few more politicians did their own leg-work rather than relying on supporters to do it for them.
 
 
 
 
Minority Report: Jersey - as culturally, ethnically and financially varied as anywhere else
 By Jerome Taylor
 
Last week I was in Jersey covering the rather grim child abuse story at the Haut de la Garenne former children's home. The only other time I'd been to Jersey was as a tourist in my teens and like most people I left with images of a well-healed idyll filled with playboy millionaires, Jersey cows and picture-postcard rural scenes.
 
That's very much the image that the island's government would like us to see, not an island steeped in secrecy where decades of horrendous child abuse was allowed to go on uninvestigated and unpunished. I imagine, as always, the reality lies somewhere in the middle (although a number of rather insensitive comments from the island's Chief Minister Frank Walker haven't exactly helped the island's desperate bid to restore its rather tainted image).
 
But my week on the island also allowed me to do some digging on the people of Jersey and to discover a people just as culturally, racially and financially mixed as anywhere else on the mainland.
 
Using a UK mainland mobile phone on Jersey is pretty costly. The main networks are Jersey Telecom and Cable and Wireless which means you get charged roaming fees like on the continent. So deciding to buy a local sim card I ended up chancing upon a member of the island's tiny Muslim community.
 
"Aki" worked in a mobile phone store in Jersey's capital St Helier and told me that about 40 Muslims lived on the island and worshipped in a small mosque not far from the city centre. He said most of them were mainlanders with Bangladeshi heritage who came to the island and set up curry restaurants (the two "Indian restaurants" I ate in that week offered distinctly Bengali cuisine).
 
I shouldn't really have been surprised that Jersey has a small Muslim community. After all, why should this small island in the Channel be any different from the mainland? In fact, since World War 2 Jersey has assimilated all sorts of different communities.
 
Take five taxi rides on the island and there's a fair chance that at least three of the drivers will be either Irish or Scottish, one will be from London and the other will be an islander. Over the past 50 years Scots, Irish and Londoners have come in their thousands and the island's population has grown from around 65,000 in the 1960s to at least 91,000. "Old Jersey" families are probably outnumbered by newcomers nowadays and the indigenous "Jersey patois" language has all but died out.
 
There is also a sizeable Portuguese community which came over in the 60s and 70s to work as farm hands in the island's crucial potato farming industry. It's not uncommon to hear Portuguese spoken and many of these families' children are bilingual.
 
The enormous expansion of the tax haven's financial industry (the world's super rich have an estimated  £247bn hidden away in Jersey) has also led to another type of immigrant - the blackberry wielding mainland bankers who fill the planes flying daily between the island and London City Airport.
 
These people have bought up vast swathes of the island and property now easily commands London prices. A small two-bedroom flat in St Helier will set you back at least £450,000 judging by some of the estate agents windows I looked in.
 
But the super rich have effectively priced the indigenous population out of the housing market, particularly those living on low incomes. Jersey might have the third highest per capita income in the world (after Bermuda and Luxembourg) but 70 per cent of the island lives on less than £34,000 a year.
 
I went down to some of the council estates (known as "States Housing") and found grim tower blocks just as rife with drugs as anywhere on the mainland. Residents complained that the cost of living has shot up over the past ten years whilst owning a house is now all but impossible.
 
But despite the horror of what has unfolded at Haut de la Garenne and the understandable question marks over why no-one spoke out sooner, the one thing that will stay with me is just how friendly the island is to outsiders. Considering the world's media descended en masse last week and began uncovering an extremely unpleasant chapter in Jersey's recent history, islanders were unfailingly courteous, helpful and in general as keen to see justice done as anyone else.
 
There's a real feeling that the abusers will now be locked up and equally importantly that those who may have conspired to ignore or cover up what happened at Haut de la Garenne will finally be forced to answer why they kept quiet.