In general, intelligent guesswork would have probably yielded as good result. In some cases, probably better. I would have always assumed Judy Martin would top her poll, but the bookmaker put her third.
Clearly CB Sports has a long way to go before they reach the accuracy of “Honest Nev”!
Senators:2/9 - Sir Philip Bailhache – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
5/2 - Ian Gorst - IN BUT WRONG PLACE
9/2 - Paul Routier - IN BUT WRONG PLACE
9/2 - Sarah Ferguson – WRONG, VOTE OUT
5/1 - Andrew Green - IN BUT WRONG PLACE
8/1 - Lyndon Farnham - RIGHT
8/1 - John Young – WRONG, VOTED OUT
9/1 - Philip Ozouf – WRONG, VOTED IN
10/1 - Sean Power
12/1 - Alan Maclean – WRONG, VOTED IN
20/1 - Zoe Cameron = WRONG, VOTED IN
25/1 - Malcolm Ferey
33/1 - Geoff Habin
80/1 - Guy de Faye
200/1 - Anne Southern
500/1 - Konrad Kruszyski
500/1 - Chris Magee
500/1 - David Richardson
1/5 odds - each way (1,2,3)
The odds for Senators were way out, and even if you consider “in but wrong place”, are still very poor.
Of those getting in:
5 out of 8 were right, but in the wrong place. Only 1 was right, and in the right place.
St Saviour No 1:4/7 - Peter McLinton, RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
6/4 - Rob Duhamel - WRONG
5/2 - Jeremy Macon – WRONG
It was Rob Duhamel, not Jeremy Macon who lost his seat.
St Saviour No 2:2/7 - Kevin Lewis - RIGHT
6/4 - Louise Doublet - RIGHT
6/1 - Maureen Morgan - RIGHT
This one was spot on.
Trinity:4/6 - Anne Pryke - RIGHT
Evens - Hugh Raymond - RIGHT
Guess work would have given a similar result.
St Peter:1/80 - Kristina Moore - RIGHT
25/1 - Debbie Hardisty - RIGHT
This was spot on, but blindingly obvious.
St Helier No 3 and 4:
11/10 - Mike Higgins – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
11/10 - Jackie Hilton – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
9/4 - Richard Rondel - IN BUT WRONG PLACE
5/2 - Christian May - WRONG
5/1 - Andrew Lewis – WRONG
6/1 - Ted Vibert
8/1 - Mary Osmond
10/1 - Laura Millen
12/1 - Mary Ayling-Phillips
16/1 - John Ttokkallos
It was Andrew Lewis who crept in to the last seat, not Christian May.
St Mary:10/11 - David Johnson
10/11 - Mark Evans
Correct
St Brelade No 1:
2/11 - Mike Jackson - WRONG
5/2 - Murray Norton - WRONG
8/1 - Angela Jeune - RIGHT
Murray got in, but my guesses were that it was close. The only certainty was Angela Jeune being last, and guesswork suggested that was very likely.
St Brelade No 2:
4/6 - Montfort Tadier – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
7/4 - Peter Troy – WRONG, CAME BELOW JEFF HATHAWAY
12/1 - Alan Maclean – WRONG, VOTED IN
20/1 - Zoe Cameron = WRONG, VOTED IN
25/1 - Malcolm Ferey
33/1 - Geoff Habin
80/1 - Guy de Faye
200/1 - Anne Southern
500/1 - Konrad Kruszyski
500/1 - Chris Magee
500/1 - David Richardson
1/5 odds - each way (1,2,3)
The odds for Senators were way out, and even if you consider “in but wrong place”, are still very poor.
Of those getting in:
5 out of 8 were right, but in the wrong place. Only 1 was right, and in the right place.
St Saviour No 1:4/7 - Peter McLinton, RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
6/4 - Rob Duhamel - WRONG
5/2 - Jeremy Macon – WRONG
It was Rob Duhamel, not Jeremy Macon who lost his seat.
St Saviour No 2:2/7 - Kevin Lewis - RIGHT
6/4 - Louise Doublet - RIGHT
6/1 - Maureen Morgan - RIGHT
This one was spot on.
Trinity:4/6 - Anne Pryke - RIGHT
Evens - Hugh Raymond - RIGHT
Guess work would have given a similar result.
St Peter:1/80 - Kristina Moore - RIGHT
25/1 - Debbie Hardisty - RIGHT
This was spot on, but blindingly obvious.
St Helier No 3 and 4:
11/10 - Mike Higgins – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
11/10 - Jackie Hilton – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
9/4 - Richard Rondel - IN BUT WRONG PLACE
5/2 - Christian May - WRONG
5/1 - Andrew Lewis – WRONG
6/1 - Ted Vibert
8/1 - Mary Osmond
10/1 - Laura Millen
12/1 - Mary Ayling-Phillips
16/1 - John Ttokkallos
It was Andrew Lewis who crept in to the last seat, not Christian May.
St Mary:10/11 - David Johnson
10/11 - Mark Evans
Correct
St Brelade No 1:
2/11 - Mike Jackson - WRONG
5/2 - Murray Norton - WRONG
8/1 - Angela Jeune - RIGHT
Murray got in, but my guesses were that it was close. The only certainty was Angela Jeune being last, and guesswork suggested that was very likely.
St Brelade No 2:
4/6 - Montfort Tadier – IN BUT WRONG PLACE
7/4 - Peter Troy – WRONG, CAME BELOW JEFF HATHAWAY
3/1 - Natalie Duffy - RIGHT
9/2 - Graham Truscott – WRONG, GOT IN
9/2 - Jane Blakeley – WRONG, CAME LAST
8/1 - Jeff Hathaway – WRONG, CAME FOURTH
10/1 Beatriz Porée – WRONG PLACE
Graham Truscott zoomed in, while Montfort came second (and lost voter share). Peter Troy was way down below Jeff Hathaway, and Jane Blakely was bottom. This bookmaker odds could not have been more wrong.
St Clement:2/7 - Susie Pinel - RIGHT
7/4 - Gerard Baudains - WRONG
9/2 - Graham Truscott – WRONG, GOT IN
9/2 - Jane Blakeley – WRONG, CAME LAST
8/1 - Jeff Hathaway – WRONG, CAME FOURTH
10/1 Beatriz Porée – WRONG PLACE
Graham Truscott zoomed in, while Montfort came second (and lost voter share). Peter Troy was way down below Jeff Hathaway, and Jane Blakely was bottom. This bookmaker odds could not have been more wrong.
St Clement:2/7 - Susie Pinel - RIGHT
7/4 - Gerard Baudains - WRONG
3/1 - Simon Brée - WRONG
8/1 - Darius Pearce - RIGHT
Simon Bree was the man coming in; Gerard Baudains out again.
St Helier No 1:11/10 - Scott Wickenden – RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
11/10 - Russell Labey - RIGHT
9/4 - Judy Martin – RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
7/2 - Nick Le Cornu – LOST BUT WRONG PLACE
5/1 - Shannen Kerrigan – LOST BUT WRONG PLACE
20/1 - Gino Risoli - RIGHT
Judy Martin romped home, and Scott was the last to get in. Of those losing, Nick Le Cornu did worse that the odds.
St Helier No 2:10/11 - Rod Bryans - RIGHT
Evens - Sam Mézec - RIGHT
3/1 - Geoff Southern - RIGHT
6/1 - Bernie Manning - RIGHT
6/1 - Martin Greene - RIGHT
This was extraordinary in that it was all correct, even the order.
St Ouen:
1/2 - Richard Renouf - RIGHT
7/4 - Chris Lamy - RIGHT
This was also right, but a foregone conclusion.
Constables:
St Mary:Evens - Juliette Gallichan - RIGHT
10/1 - John Le Bailly – RIGHT
This was what guesswork suggested, a close call.
8/1 - Darius Pearce - RIGHT
Simon Bree was the man coming in; Gerard Baudains out again.
St Helier No 1:11/10 - Scott Wickenden – RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
11/10 - Russell Labey - RIGHT
9/4 - Judy Martin – RIGHT BUT WRONG PLACE
7/2 - Nick Le Cornu – LOST BUT WRONG PLACE
5/1 - Shannen Kerrigan – LOST BUT WRONG PLACE
20/1 - Gino Risoli - RIGHT
Judy Martin romped home, and Scott was the last to get in. Of those losing, Nick Le Cornu did worse that the odds.
St Helier No 2:10/11 - Rod Bryans - RIGHT
Evens - Sam Mézec - RIGHT
3/1 - Geoff Southern - RIGHT
6/1 - Bernie Manning - RIGHT
6/1 - Martin Greene - RIGHT
This was extraordinary in that it was all correct, even the order.
St Ouen:
1/2 - Richard Renouf - RIGHT
7/4 - Chris Lamy - RIGHT
This was also right, but a foregone conclusion.
Constables:
St Mary:Evens - Juliette Gallichan - RIGHT
10/1 - John Le Bailly – RIGHT
This was what guesswork suggested, a close call.
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment